Hi Dakota...I'm back.
First, would you please use the "edit option" and add the tags "Leaders" and "Arborists"? They might be your best help and tagging it brings it to their attention.
I think this is what happened. Does it sound right to you?......
4:49 you created Ephraim Adams-19437 as the father of Levi Adams.
4:50 you created Sarah Garner as the wife of Ephraim.
10:48 you adopted Ephraim Adams 5908 (was a match for your Ephraim)
10:51 you tried to merge them together, 19437 + 5908 but accidently transposed the numbers and entered 5098, then they were combined. (it probably looked very confusing all of a sudden)
11:02 the new combined Ephraim Adams-5098 was then merged with Ephraim Adams-5908.
Now there is no 19437 or 5908, but instead all 3 are now Ephraim Adams-5098.
The good news is that the original merge you wished was completed. The bad news is that whoever Adams-5098 is has vanished. Unfortunately the Profile Manager is no longer a member and cannot be contacted as normal.
I think you should contact Admin WikiTree. The link is on her profile.
Please let me know how it turns out. They respond quickly and are very helpfull!