need help with Tillman line

Question

My Great Grandmother was Lucy Ann Tillman Carlisle. I have found a line for her on Familysearch, but I would like to make sure its right, could anyone tell me how to do this?

Comments

Forget the "line for her on Family Search" method and just keep adding individual census records.  I can see I added the 1930 and 1940 census records but I'm not sure where the parents came from.  I also added the WWI for Earle Eugene Carlisle but I can see there are several Early Carlisle in the area so care needs to be taken not to confuse him with someone else.

Answer 1

Was Tillman her maiden name and Carlisle her married name,Who did she

marrie,Where did she live and where born??.Family Search.Org,some things they

have are right.But some of there info is based on family trees,which are not always

proven.

Comments

Her birth name was Lucy Ann Tillman. She married Earle Eugene Carlisle, I don't know the date or location. She was born in Georgia in 1904, and she and Earl moved to S.C. sometime between 1925 and 1928. The family line I found on Family Search was user submitted, thats the only reason I questioned if I was on the right track.

---

Parents are (I'm pretty sure) George Thomas Tillman and Katie L. Pye

Answer 2

According to the US Census 1920 records, this has the same birth year and mother as you do.  But, all the children are different.  

 

https://familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:MJ68-VZV

Comments

According to the US Census 1910 this link has the same parents and same birth year as Lucy, but again, children are different.  https://familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:ML2F-SQL

---

Sally,

Since Lucy isn't showning any siblings on the Wikitree except for one which is hidden by privacy, which children are different?   The children in the 1910 and 1920 census would be her siblings and not the children that are hers from the 1930 and 1940 census.  Right?

Answer 3

Certificate of death, 60-019908, Reg.Dist. 23A,

Earl Eugene Carlisle died Dec 13 1960. Lancaster County Georgia. Date of birth

Nov 27 1897. Occupation Weaver,Textile Industry. Wife Lucy Tillman Carlisle,All

his census records shows he was a Weaver.

Father Robert Carlisle,Mother Elizabeth Clark.Died of Myocardial Infarction.All listed
on Death Certificate.

1917 WW1 draft registration card, Earley E Carlisle,Note Earley,later records show

Earl. His birth date in his own writing shown as Nov 27 1896,He was born Flowery Branch Georgia.Noted he was working for his mother Elizabeth Carlisle.

Answer 4

1910 Census, Lucy Tilman, born abt 1906 Georgia. Home in 1910 Lawrence

Jasper Georgia, Father George Thomas Tilman, Mother Kittie l.Tilman,

says kittie but later is Katie, who is Katie Loftin Pye.Actually Lucy born Sept. 10

1904. There is evidence she died about 1952.Also Lucy Tillman listed in 1920

Census. In 1920 living in Jefferson, Jackson County, Georgia.Those 2 Census

also show all her Siblings.

1930 Census Earle E Carlisle born about 1899, in Georgia, in 1930 living in

Calhoun Falls,Abbeville,South Carolina,shows 5 children.Earl E Carlisle born

April 1898,per 1900 Census.

Answer 5

Lucy Tillman

mentioned in the record of Lucile Carlisle

Name: Lucy Tillman

Gender: Female

Husband: E. E. Carlisle

Daughter: Lucile Carlisle

Other information in the record of Lucile Carlisle

from Georgia Deaths

Name: Lucile Carlisle

Event Date: 06 Aug 1922

Age (Formatted): 15 months

Event Place: Jefferson, Jackson, Georgia, United States

Birth Year (Estimated): 1921

Birthplace: Ga.

Gender: Female

Race: White

Ethnicity: American

Father's Name: E. E. Carlisle

Mother's Name: Lucy Tillman

GS Film number:

2297343

Digital Folder Number: 4178800 , Image Number: 00133 , Reference ID: 18170

Attach to Family Tree 

View the document

View the original document to see a piece of history

Download document

Georgia Deaths, 1914-1927

Search collection

About this collection

Citing this Record

"Georgia Deaths, 1914-1927," index and images, FamilySearch (https://familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:JDXH-4LP : accessed 21 May 2015), Lucy Tillman in entry for Lucile Carlisle, 06 Aug 1922, Jefferson, Jackson, Georgia, United States; citing reference 18170, Department of Archives and History, Atlanta; FHL microfilm 2297343.