Question

Can a Pre-1500 Certified member merge Fitzalan-379 into FitzAlan-148

Comments

Note Richardson calls her Alice Arundel, not FitzAlan.

https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=8JcbV309c5UC&pg=RA1-PA420

---

Sorry, posted wrong link, now fixed, at the umpteenth attempt

---

Can these requests for pre-1500 merges please be posted to Requests for Genealogy Help? They're not really policy/style topics. Thanks.

---

The gizmo supplies that setting as the preset default, so I don't expect many people will change it.

The gizmo appears when you try to complete a merge that needs a badge you haven't got.  Pre-1500 badgeholders won't see it, so they're all mystified where all these messages are coming from.

---

So the gizmo automatically posts the message to Policy/Style? Can the gizmo be changed?

Answer 1

So i thought I'd chime in, and I looked at your link, and read the whole snippet on Alice, and as the previous pages are not available at that source, the only thing I can point out is the compilers note "The best possibility which I can propound is that Bartholomew Collingridge married and otherwise unrecorded daughter of Sir John Arundell, by his first marriage-...". John being neither the listed father here, and the listed father of both, hae different parents, I would suggest more research and-or sources to back up your request, AND verify both Alice FitzAlan/Collinridge. But that is my opinion, and I like to see 'in context' sourcing.

Comments

For the moment I've set them as unmerged matches, pending a possible change of Last Name at Birth (LNAB) to Arundel, and more research into her name, parents etc.  At the moment neither profile has sources that are considered reliable.

---

The quoted text is from the source cited.  Richardson often cites sources that he rejects, and quotes what they say.

---

FitzAlan-615 is the badged-up version.  But not the right final ID.