Big Turkey (Cornstalk) Shawnee is currently protected by the Native Americans Project for reasons described below. Join: Native Americans Project Discuss: native_americans
Research suggests that this person may never have existed. See the text for details.
This person's existence and relationships were introduced by Don Greene in his book, Shawnee Heritage.[1] This self-published book contains thousands of names of undocumented Native Americans, including claimed information on their lineages, clans, political divisions, treaties signed and battles fought. Much of it has been proven to be false. See category link above about the validity of this work. There is no historical documentation of this person's existence or relationships.
Disputed Existence
The parents of Hokolesqua, known as Cornstalk, are unknown. He said in a speech that his father was White Fish, a Shawnee man. [2]
The Moravian Missionaries say he was the son or grandson of Paxinosa. [2]
A chief named Cornstalk/Hokoleskwa did exist. He lived from about 1720-1775, so is not any of the people listed on this profile even though the bio mentions him.
All the people named as parents, siblings, spouse, and children of Big Turkey as well as Big Turkey himself are mythical.
False Biography
Don Greene claimed that he:
was a war chief in the Shawnee Nation; which was basically everything east of the Mississippi but not the leader of the whole tribe.
had a son Okowellos Cornstalk born:1740, in Ohio,
was the only Chief of the Entire Shawnee Nation
passed away in 1694.
Sources
↑ Shawnee Heritage By Don Greene, Noel Schutz, 2008, available at lulu.com.
↑ 2.02.1 Sugden, John. Cornstalk, in American National Biography, Oxford University Press,1999. Sugden
Hop Cornstalk-1 was created by Glenn Brackin through the import of Brackin Family Tree.ged on Dec 2, 2014.
Is Big Turkey your ancestor? Please don't go away! Login to collaborate or comment, or
contact
a profile manager, or ask our community of genealogists a question.
There is no documentation for this person. The Shawnee lived in the area where what are now Ohio, West Virginia, and Kentucky come together until the middle of the 18th century. Intermarriage with Cherokee prior to removal in the mid1800s was rare.
I'm reviewing all the Powhatan surname profiles. This one came up. I'm having difficult figuring out who was real and who wasn't and what we need to do to this set of profiles. Can you please advise me, Kathie?