Magna Carta Trail Pending
This profile is in a Magna Carta trail that is pending development. See text for details. Join: Magna Carta Project Discuss: magna_carta
John Montagu, K.G., 3rd Earl of Salisbury, Lord Montagu, Lord Monthermer[1] (2nd Baron of Montacute & Monthermer), Deputy Earl Marshal of England[2] and
By an unknown mistress, Thomas had an illegitimate son, John.[7]
Thomas was "summoned to Parliament as Earl of Salisbury October 1409."[1] "Thomas (de Montacute) 7th Earl of Salisbury" was made Knight of the Garter after 8 January 1413/14.[8] "Montagu... spent most of the rest of his life as a soldier in France, leading troops in the various skirmishes and sieges that were central to that part of the Hundred Years' War. In 1425 he captured the city of Le Mans and fought at the Siege of Orléans in 1428 at which he lost his life."[2][9]
Thomas Montague, considered the most effective English military commander of his time, was leading English forces in France when he was mortally wounded.[2][10] He died 3 November 1428 at Meung-sur-Loire, near Beaugency, "of wounds received a few days previously during the Siege of Orléans."[1][11]
'The will of "Thomas Montacute Earl of Salisbury, Perch, and Lord Monthermer", undated, chose burial "at Bustleham" [Bisham], bequeathed property to "my uncle Richard de Montacute Knight...John my bastard son"...'[5]
"Sir Thomas Montagu, 4th Earl of Salisbury, Count of Perche,... was buried at Bisham Priory, Berkshire. His widow, Alice, married (3rd) by license dated 11 Nov. 1430 William [de la] Pole, K.G."[1]
Research Notes
Although many sources say he was at Harfleur and Agincourt,[12] Richardson quotes from "Nicholas Hist. of the Battle of Agincourt (1827)":[1]
"... nor, though the earl of Salisbury contracted to furnish a certain number of followers, does it appear he was either at Harfleur or Agincourt [in 1415]"
Sources
↑ 1.001.011.021.031.041.051.061.071.081.091.101.111.121.131.141.15 Douglas Richardson, Royal Ancestry: A Study in Colonial and Medieval Families, 5 vols., ed. Kimball G. Everingham (Salt Lake City, Utah: the author, 2013), Volume IV, pages 120-124, MONTAGU #9, #10 Thomas Montagu, K.G.
↑#Wikipedia says 13 June 1388, apparently citing Lundy's database, which says "before 13 June 1388" (citing an e-mail, see database for details):
Thomas Montagu, "thepeerage" (website, compiled by Darryl Lundy, Ngaio, Wellington, New Zealand; accessed 8 August 2018)
↑ Birth location of "Salisbury, Wiltshire" was deleted from profile's datafield. Richardson's entry for Thomas Montagu in Royal Ancestry does not give a birth location, nor do the entries for him posted by #Wikipedia, #Lewis, #Lundy, or #Cawley (checked on 8 August 2018). The location is apparently from an unsourced Pedigree File:
"Pedigree Resource File," database (FamilySearch : accessed 22 July 2018), entry for (Sir) THOMAS DE MONTAGUE (Knight of the Garter); "2018 recovered tree - July" file (2:2:2:MM6D-K79), submitted 13 July 2018 by HummingbirdAbernathy [identity withheld for privacy].
↑ William Arthur Shaw and George Dames Burtchaell, The Knights of England. A complete record from the earliest time to the present day...,page 9 (accessed 8 August 2018)
↑ See the Wikisource page on him from Encylopædia Britannica for additional details of his military campaigns. See also #Research Notes, above.
↑ The death location datafield previously had "Meung-sur-Loire, Beaugency, Loiret, Centre, France" but no text to support it - perhaps the modern name?
↑ For example, #Wikipedia, citing the Dictionary of National Biography's article on Thomas de Montacute by William Hunt (accessed 8 August 2018).
This profile has been identified by Douglas Richardson as in a trail from Gateway Ancestor Maria Johanna Somerset to Magna Carta Surety Baron William d'Aubigny. The trail has not yet been developed, though substantial parts overlap with other trails. Details of it can be found HERE.
Needs Development: This profile needs development against the project's checklist to bring it up to current project standards. ~ Thiessen-117 18:09, 22 September 2020 (UTC)
See Base Camp for more information about identified Magna Carta trails and their status. See the project's glossary for project-specific terms, such as a "badged trail".
among the changes made by the import of the FamilySearch Family Tree information was changing "Meung-sur-Loire, France" to "Meung-sur-Loire, Orléans, Loiret, Centre-Val de Loire, France". Should that be the death location? A footnote says
↑ The death location datafield previously had "Meung-sur-Loire, Beaugency, Loiret, Centre, France" but no text to support it - perhaps the modern name?
Only Meung-sur-Loire is cited in text, which describes it as "near Beaugency," and quotes Richardson as saying Thomas died "of wounds received a few days previously during the Siege of Orléans."
The Familysearch information is the modern name, using modern administrative divisions, which did not exist until much later, and on my understanding of WT guidance, should definitely not be used. I would myself stick with Meung-sur-Loire, France. The Département of Loiret was created in 1790.
I believe this was caused by me using the WikiTree familysearch watchlist match program this afternoon. Is there a way to alert users of potential problems? I want the appropriate data and formats, too. Can the profile be corrected or restored? Normally this match program can be helpful. Seeing the danger, I need to be much more cautious.
Thanks, Ron. If this information came from Familysearch family trees, like other family trees on the web, they are unreliable sources. A number of Projects, including the Magna Carta Project, have heavy health warnings about Familysearch trees. The pre-1700 help page on WikiTree says they are not reliable sources: https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Help:Pre-1700_Profiles.
Any suggestions from Familysearch for watchlists are just an indication that there is something that may be worth exploring, not an indication that the information is good. A lot of watchlist suggestions - not just Familysearch ones - are incorrect.
I haven't used the import feature before, so I don't know how it works. Profiles can be restored, and I did that in this case.
When you look at Changes for a profile & select the edit details, you'll see a restore option at the top of the two columns. When you select it, you have options to select areas of the profiles that changed (not all changes can be reversed, but in this case, they could). What I do when I restore a profile is then add new information to the restored profile - you'll see the FamilySearch reference added under "See also" (the precise birth date was already footnoted). update: The FamilySearch reference was deleted (FamilyTrees are not reliable sources).
558 Wikidata - Different death date: no idea where Wikidata got the 12 November date. WikiTree citation is to Richardson, but other sources have 3 November 1428 also (including Wikipedia).
554 Wikidata - Imprecise birth date: 1388 as birth year is sourced to Richardson (who uses the first "aged 12 in 1400" instead of "24 in 1415"). Wikipedia's precise date (13 June 1388) is referenced in a footnote (it's apparently from thepeerage.com, which says "before 13 June 1388" but does not cite a reliable source).
both Cawley & Richardson say marriage with Eleanor was "on or before" 23 May 1399. I went through the fine print in Richardson but that date was not specifically mentioned. Cawley does not footnote the date.
from Marlyn Lewis's database, marriage is "circa 23 May 1399" - that needs to be checked against Richardson. Marriage "c. 1405" has no support but is likely when the marriage was consummated (daughter's profile has Oct. 1405 birth date). The 23 May 1399 date is probably the contract date.
When addressing data base errors 408, 554 and 558, I noticed the note at the very bottom, so edited for the rip and paste. Added citations and corrected minor errors and typos. Hope this helps. Let me know if you'd prefer I restore it -- I probably should have asked first.
2nd Wife, Chaucer-1, citations and sources need to be added for:
Bio Detail:
Family 2: Alice Chaucer b. c 1404, d. 20 May 1475 or 9 Jun 1475
Sources:
? Douglas Richardson, Royal Ancestry, Vol. IV, p. 121-122.
? Douglas Richardson, Magna Carta Ancestry, 2nd Edition, Vol. III, p. 161-162.
? Douglas Richardson, Magna Carta Ancestry, 2nd Edition, Vol. III, p. 159-160
? Douglas Richardson, Royal Ancestry, Vol. III, p. 208-209
? Douglas Richardson, Plantagenet Ancestry, p. 689.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thomas_Montacute,_4th_Earl_of_Salisburyhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Siege_of_Orl%C3%A9ans
Marlyn Lewis need to be added to this protected profile. I am the pre-1500 certified profile manager, but I'm blocked from editing. Can someone help?
De Montague-10 and Montagu-26 appear to represent the same person because: Montagu-26 is correct LNAB per European Aristocrats Project guidelines & is the project-protected profile.
Only Meung-sur-Loire is cited in text, which describes it as "near Beaugency," and quotes Richardson as saying Thomas died "of wounds received a few days previously during the Siege of Orléans."
Could someone better at geography than I am take a look? WikiTree guidelines say to "use their conventions, not ours", meaning the location should be what Thomas would have called it, not what it's called today. See https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Help:Location_Fields#Location_Field_Style_Guide
Any suggestions from Familysearch for watchlists are just an indication that there is something that may be worth exploring, not an indication that the information is good. A lot of watchlist suggestions - not just Familysearch ones - are incorrect.
edited by Michael Cayley
When you look at Changes for a profile & select the edit details, you'll see a restore option at the top of the two columns. When you select it, you have options to select areas of the profiles that changed (not all changes can be reversed, but in this case, they could). What I do when I restore a profile is then add new information to the restored profile - you'll see the FamilySearch reference added under "See also" (the precise birth date was already footnoted). update: The FamilySearch reference was deleted (FamilyTrees are not reliable sources).
To see what had been added/changed & what I reversed, see https://www.wikitree.com/index.php?title=Montagu-26&diff=prev&oldid=106576007
edited by Liz (Noland) Shifflett
558 Wikidata - Different death date: no idea where Wikidata got the 12 November date. WikiTree citation is to Richardson, but other sources have 3 November 1428 also (including Wikipedia).
554 Wikidata - Imprecise birth date: 1388 as birth year is sourced to Richardson (who uses the first "aged 12 in 1400" instead of "24 in 1415"). Wikipedia's precise date (13 June 1388) is referenced in a footnote (it's apparently from thepeerage.com, which says "before 13 June 1388" but does not cite a reliable source).
Cheers, Liz
Bio Detail: Family 2: Alice Chaucer b. c 1404, d. 20 May 1475 or 9 Jun 1475 Sources: ? Douglas Richardson, Royal Ancestry, Vol. IV, p. 121-122. ? Douglas Richardson, Magna Carta Ancestry, 2nd Edition, Vol. III, p. 161-162. ? Douglas Richardson, Magna Carta Ancestry, 2nd Edition, Vol. III, p. 159-160 ? Douglas Richardson, Royal Ancestry, Vol. III, p. 208-209 ? Douglas Richardson, Plantagenet Ancestry, p. 689. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thomas_Montacute,_4th_Earl_of_Salisbury http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Siege_of_Orl%C3%A9ans Marlyn Lewis need to be added to this protected profile. I am the pre-1500 certified profile manager, but I'm blocked from editing. Can someone help?