no image
Privacy Level: Open (White)

Daniel Blevins Jr. (bef. 1741 - aft. 1794)

Daniel Blevins Jr.
Born before in Prince George's County, Province of Marylandmap [uncertain]
Ancestors ancestors
Son of and [uncertain]
Brother of [half]
Husband of — married 1760 in Colony of Virginiamap
Descendants descendants
Died after after age 53 in Grayson, Virginia, United Statesmap [uncertain]
Profile last modified | Created 10 Apr 2012
This page has been accessed 4,055 times.
US Southern Colonies.
Daniel Blevins Jr. resided in the Southern Colonies in North America before 1776.
Join: US Southern Colonies Project
Discuss: southern_colonies

Contents

Biography

Birth

Daniel Blevin (aka Blevins) was born before 1741, most likely either in in the Monocacy Hundred in the Province of Maryland, or in the Colony of Virginia. He was the son of Daniel Blevins and, possibly, Daniel's wife Sarah (____). [1]

Migration to Virginia

Beginning in the late 1730s, the Blevins families left Maryland and migrated to Virginia. Most settled initially in Goochland County, Virginia, but it is unclear whether this Daniel's father Daniel ever settled there. The first appearance of his father Daniel in the extant records is much further west, along the banks of the Smith River in what was then Lunenburg County, where the older Daniel first appears in the court records beginning in 1746.[2]

In 1752, Halifax County was carved from the western portion of Lunenburg, and on 8 April 1762, both Daniel Blevins Sr. and Daniel Blevins Jr. filed land entries in Halifax County for acreage along Little Marrowbone Creek and other tributaries of the Smith River. A land entry record filed by Merry Webb on 17 February 1763 again references the Daniel Blevins entry.[3]

In 1767, Pittsylvania County was carved from the western portion of Halifax. In 1771, the older Daniel was still living in Pittsylvania County, but his son Daniel had migrated further west to what was then Botetourt County. In 1771, both Daniels and Sarah the wife of the older Daniel executed a document of particular importance for Blevins researchers: a power of attorney in connection with their efforts to pursue a property interest that Daniel Sr and his son Daniel Jr claimed in land located in Westerly, Rhode Island. This power of attorney was executed on 1 July 1771, and proved in court in Pittsylvania County, Virginia, on 27 September 1771.[4]

In 1772, Fincastle County was created from the western portion of Botetourt, and in 1773, several Blevins men appear on John Montgomeries [sic] List of Tithables for Fincastle County, including Daniel as well as William, John, and James.[5] Given his confirmed presence in Botetourt County in 1771 based on the power of attorney, the Daniel on that list is likely this one.

American Revolution

A Daniel Blevins enlisted in the Montgomery County Militia, 14th Regiment on 21 Jan 1776 under Col. Charles Lewis, and Capt. John Cox. He is noted as "deserting on 17 March", on the May 1777 Military Rolls. (U.S. Revolutionary War Roll, 1775-1783)

On 30 Sep 1777 he took "The Virginia Oath of Allegiance", under Capt. John Cox. Daniel appears on the Loyalist Insurrection in 16 July 1779, the sworn deposition of Capt. John Cox which begins with "whereas the most daring conspiracy and insurrection" "within the bounds of Captain Cox and Osborne's Companies". Others that appear on 1777 Montgomery County Militia include sons' Richard and Jonathan Blevins. ("The Blevins Men of the Revolution", page 11, "Virginia Military Records", page 211. Blevens)

Montgomery County, Virginia

Montgomery County was created from Fincastle in 1777. Daniel Blevins appears on the personal property tax lists for Montgomery County in 1787, 1788, and 1789.[6] Significantly, appearing immediately next to Daniel Blevins on these lists are:

  • in 1787, James Blevins, identified as "son of D."
  • in 1788, James Blevins, again identified as "son of D."
  • in 1789, Elisha, James, and John Blevins; both James and John are identified as "son of D."

The identification of James and John Blevins as the son of Daniel on these lists was apparently to distinguish them from other James and John Blevins which appear elsewhere in Montgomery County at the same time.

Wythe & Grayson County, Virginia

In 1790, Wythe County was created from the western portion of Montgomery; and in 1793, Grayson county was carved from the southern portion of Wythe. In 1794, a number of Blevins men appear on the tax lists for Grayson County, Virginia, including two Daniels.[7] It is likely that one of the two men named Daniel Blevins who appear in Grayson County in 1794 is this same Daniel.

A Daniel Blevins appears again on those lists in 1797, and appears to be listed as possibly exempt (perhaps due to his advanced age?).[8] He does not seem to appear in the tax lists after that.

The circumstances of this Daniel's death are uncertain, but he likely died after 1797, probably in Grayson County, Virginia.

Children

The identity of the children of this Daniel Blevins has been controversial and is the subject of ongoing research and collaboration among interested WikITree members.

Based on the Montgomery County Tax Lists for 1787-89 cited above, and the family clusters on the Grayson County tax lists from 1797-1803,[9] the children of this Daniel and an unknown mother probably include:

  • James
  • John
  • Elisha

Some researchers also identify additional brothers

  • Jonathan
  • Richard

Research and collaboration to sort this out is ongoing.

Research Notes

Proof of Parental Relationship

The 1771 power of attorney establishes that Daniel was the son of Daniel and also that the older Daniel's wife in 1771 was named Sarah (____).[4] It is uncertain whether this was the older Daniel's only wife, and therefore it is uncertain whether this Sarah was the younger Daniel's mother.

Date and Location of Birth

The land transactions involving both Daniel Sr and Daniel Jr in Halifax County in 1762 establish that the younger Daniel was already 21 by then, indicating a birth year of 1741 or earlier.[3] For the reasons described in his profile, Daniel's father was likely born between 1710-14 and was living in the Monocacy Hundred in what was then St. George's County, Maryland, in 1733. The Blevins families began migration from Maryland to Virginia in the 1730s, so it is likely that Daniel Jr. was born either in St. George's County, Maryland, or in the Colony of Virginia, between 1731- 1741.

Possible Presence in North Carolina

A Daniel Blevins served on the Royal North Carolina Regiment Loyalist Volunteers roster in Oct 1779, under Lt. Col. John Hamilton. He appears on subsequent Loyalist lists for 1777, 1781, 1782, and 1783. (Montgomery Militia, Loyalist Insurrection, and Loyalist records "The Blevins Men of the Revolution"..., "The Loyalists of North Carolina"..)

Daniel Blevins documented "encampment" along Flat Creek, on the French Broad River in modern Buncombe, North Carolina. Original land grant if any unknown, and is being sought. Daniel did own land in Montgomery by "entitlement" in the year 1778. He is referenced in the following document:

North Carolina Land Grants dated 6 Sep 1782 for William Roberts, Buncombe, North Carolina, 296A-505.

  • "I have surveyed a tract of land for William Roberts containing three hundred and fifty acres, lying on Daniel Blevenses (sic) camp (t) branch, the first big branch lying on Flat Creek, on the north side of the French Broad River". (North Carolina, U.S., Land Grant Files)

- It is not clear, but this is likely the Daniel who appeared in Buncombe, North Carolina, based on his absence on the 1782 Montgomery County Tax lists, and his Loyalist affiliation. (Ange Marshall-21076) See comments below.

Transcription of 1771 Power of Attorney

From an earlier version of the profile:

Daniel Sr. and son Daniel Jr. signed a power of attorney to assign their friend James Rentfrow, to recover land in Westerly RI in 1771. From "Washington Co., RI Records" the following is taken: "Power of Attorney - 1 July 1771 - We Daniel Blevins, Sr. of Pittsylvania County in Virginia and Daniel Blevins, son of said Daniel Blevins, in Botetourt County in Virginia, do appoint our Trusty friend James Rentfrow, Sr. of Pittsylvania Co., VA as our true and lawful attorney for us in our name and to our use to ask Demand Recover or Receive of and from Joseph Stantone in Westerly formerly Narragency in new ingland, one piece of Land containing 100 acres more or less in Westerly new ingland....our sole and full Power and authority to follow such legal Courses....as we our Self might or could do were we Personally present....all things which may be necessary Concerning the Premises. Signed Daniel Blevins, Sr. his x mark; Sarah her mark; Daniel Blevins, Jr. his mark; Wit: Thos. Flowers, Geo. Lumkin, Robt., Lumkin, Robt. Pewsey; Rec: 27 Sep. 1771."

Sources

  1. See discussions of "Proof of Parental Relationship" and "Date and Location of Birth"in the Research Notes.
  2. See profile for Daniel Blevins.
  3. 3.0 3.1 Chiarito, Entry record book, 1737-1770, based on Fansler index.
  4. 4.0 4.1 Pittsylvania County Virginia Deed Book No. 2 1770-1772, p. 317-18; Digital Images, FamilySearch, “Deed book, v. 1, 1767-1770 (includes list of surveys 1768-1769) -- Deed book, v. 2, 1770-1772;” FHL microfilm 33,262; DGS 7,646,004. Copy with transcription, WikiTree (https://www.wikitree.com/photo.php/6/6e/Blevins-111.pdf : accessed 29 Jun 2021.
  5. Richard Slatten, "A Tithable List for Botecourt Parish, Fincastle County, Virginia, 1772, 1773," Magazine of Virginia Genealogy, Vol. 25, No. 1, Feb. 1987, 11-19, at 17; images, Ancestry.com, (https://www.ancestry.com/imageviewer/collections/6131/images/VGS_1987_01_01_0020 : accessed 5 Dec 2020).
  6. Montgomery County Personal Property Tax Lists 1787-89 (microfilm); digital images, FamilySearch, "Personal property tax lists 1787-1812 (Missing 1808)," (https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:3Q9M-CS79-KZW9-L : accessed 7 Jul 2021), images 115 (1787), 155 (1788), & 216 (1789); FHL microfilm 1,870,165; DGS 7,856,147.
  7. Grayson County Personal Property Tax List 1794 (microfilm); digital images, FamilySearch, "Personal property tax lists, 1794-1827," (https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:3Q9M-CSQ2-Q3Q5-M : accessed 5 Jul 2021), images 16 & 17; FHL microfilm 2,024,555; DGS 7,849,125.
  8. Grayson County Personal Property Tax List 1794 (microfilm) , image 78.
  9. Grayson County Personal Property Tax Lists 1794 (microfilm). FamilySearch, “Personal property tax lists, 1794-1827,” (https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:3Q9M-CSQ2-Q3Q5-M : accessed 14 Aug 2021), images 78 (1797: James, Daniel (Exem?), & Elisha); 103 (1788: Elisha, James & John); 177 (1801: Elisha, James, & Daniel); 201 (1802: John, Daniel, James, Elisha, Stephen); & 225 (1803: James & Elisha); FHL microfilm 2,024,555; DGS 7,849,125.

See also:

  • U.S., Compiled Revolutionary War Military Service Records,1775 - 1783
  • U.S. Revolutionary War Rolls, 1775-1783 (1777)
  • North Carolina, U.S., Land Grant Files, 1693-1960 (William Roberts, 6 Sep 1782, Buncombe, NC, 296A-505)
  • "The Loyalists in North Carolina During the Revolution", Robert O. Demond, Duke University Press, Durham, North Carolina, 1940.
  • "The Blevins Men of the Revolution; Blevins Patriots and Loyalists in the Southern Campaigns", pages 6,7, and 11. Robert P. Blevins, Acme, Pennsylvania, 2021
  • "Virginia Military Records"; The Virginia Magazine of History and Biography, The William and Mary College Quarterly, and Tylers Quarterly", page 211, (Capt. Cox's Company, Sept 30, 1777 Militia list). Baltimore Genealogical Publishing, 1983. (Daniel Blevens)





Sponsored Search by Ancestry.com

DNA Connections
It may be possible to confirm family relationships with Daniel by comparing test results with other carriers of his Y-chromosome or his mother's mitochondrial DNA. Y-chromosome DNA test-takers in his direct paternal line on WikiTree: It is likely that these autosomal DNA test-takers will share some percentage of DNA with Daniel:

Have you taken a DNA test? If so, login to add it. If not, see our friends at Ancestry DNA.



Comments: 107

Leave a message for others who see this profile.
There are no comments yet.
Login to post a comment.
Nice to see all this work being done on the Blevins/Blevans - wondering if anyone knows which Daniel is in the Revolutionary War era Cox's Militia list & Herbert's Militia in Grayson Co, VA. I had thought these were colonist militias, but willing to be corrected.

I tried sorting out Blevans one from the other "back in the aughts" and gave up chiefly due to the contention between some of the researchers and the plethora of same named individuals. Now that I've done autosomal testing, I've discovered that people related to the Blevans/Osborn(Ausborn)/Howards seem to share matches with me and people from at least 5 of my 8 greatgrandfathers. There's marrying cousins and then there's this batch. Trying to figure out shares from folks with 30 cM is tough because it seems that they are sharing DNA from two totally different lines in my family at a much lower rate. So what seems like a slam dunk 3rd cousin winds up being a 6C1R and a 5C and a 5C2R, all in different research sets. Rowan, Rutherford, NC and Grayson, VA are the common locations, followed by mid 19th C emigrations to Missouri.

My semi-documented individual is Stephen Ausborn Blevans (1787 ish - 1851) son of Richard Blevans & Hannah Ausborn who were married in Rutherford Co, NC. Current theory is that Richard Blevans and numerous Oz/Osbornes served in the militias raised in the New River Valley and then settled in Grayson Co, VA after a short period in western NC. See lists here https://www.newrivernotes.com/revolutionary-war-soldiers-nrv/.

In 1830 Stephen A Blevans of Bond, IL provided a statement certifying that Joseph Evans had received a certificate in 1819 allowing him to claim a pension for service in the Revolution. Stephe said that they were both living in Marion Co, TN at the time. The following year Stephen moved to Crawford Co, Missouri, according to his son Jonathan's autobiography written in 1932. Same autobiography has him in Pulaski (Miller) Co, MO from 1834-1841. However, in 1840, I have two Stephens - Stephen A in Bond Co, IL and another Stephen with children the right age for my guy's kids is in Platte, MO. As I said, there are multiple individuals with the same first name in every generation.

posted by Nancy Caton
edited by Nancy Caton
Daniel's wife was a Miss Sutton who was the sister of John Sutton who lived near the hanging rock in South Carolina as proven by a statement made by Elijah P. Cushman in support of the Revolutionary War pension application of his son James,

From the pension application of James Blevens (Blevins) S32121 State of Indiana, Lawrence County: County Probate Court State of Indiana Greene County On this the 22nd day of June 1833 personally appeared before me Elijah P. Cushman a Justice of the Peace in and for the County aforesaid Robert Ellis a resident of said County aged 76 years the first day of last February who being first duly sworn according to law makes oath and saith that when he was a volunteer in the Army of the Revolution of the time he was stationed at Siege of Ninety Six in the State of South Carolina became acquainted with James Evans [sic Blevins] now a resident of Lawrence County in this State...That in the few days after the battle of the Eutaw Springs the said Blevins was taken to his uncle's John Sutton's who lived near the hanging rock in South Carolina...

posted by Alton Blevins
Thank you for the extensive deep-dives & work again, Alton! It's much appreciated & if not for people like you, much of this might never get straightened out.
posted by Day (Bredleau) Thomas
Additional child of Daniel Blevins Jr.

Infant Blevins female.

Birth 1760/1761 --- Death 1760/1761.

6949-Hooper

posted by Richard Hooper
Thank you Richard - what source are these claims about the additional children based on? There is a lot of confusion surrounding these early Blevins families so we need to take a careful look at the sources before adding additional children.
posted by Scott McClain
Additional Child of Daniel Blevins Jr.

Willian Blevins'

Birth 1757/1758 --- Death 1847.

6940-Hooper.

posted by Richard Hooper
Unfortunately, Daniel (Jr.) has not proven as a son. And as Scott McClain has correctly demonstrated - there are many Blevins making everything complicated. A younger Daniel seems unlikely as an "encampment". With Daniel Sr. not listed on 1782 Montgomery Tax lists, and a known Loyalist - this is likely him.

This area of North Carolina was a known Loyalist "hub" for obvious reasons. William Roberts who is sourced w/ land grant is another person being examined. There is integral relationships between families and researching history takes time to clarify. There is always need for corrections, this is part of the process. Daniel Sr. likely returned to Virginia, after the conflict was over. Daniel's sons are documented in the building of the Burke/ Buncombe roads (which seems to follow Daniel's 1782 residency)

I will return to help when done with my other Wikitree family members.

posted by [Living Marshall]
Thanks for your efforts Ange. This is a very challenging family. I still have it on my to-do list to come back to the project too, and will try to see if I can help sort it out, hopefully sometime this summer.
posted by Scott McClain
I've chosen to edit my comment. Here's what I have added to my biography for this Daniel..

There's a trace of Daniel (or his father) in Burke County in a survey record dated September 6, 1782 -- "I have surveyed a tract of land for William Roberts containing three hundred and fifty acres, lying on Daniel Blevinses camp branch, the first big branch lying on Flat Creek on north side of French Broad River." Daniel was about 22 and his father about 42, and both were old enough to make camp on a branch of Flat Creek in the part of Burke that became Buncombe County in 1791, and present day Transylvania County in 1861. This Daniel could have been the father -- he wasn't listed in the 1782 Montgomery County, Virginia Personal Property Tax List. He could also have been the son -- he spent many months trekking around North Carolina during the war and he may well have seen a locale where he wanted to live. In any case, father or son, there's no record of his ever getting a survey or grant for the land.

posted by Alton Blevins
edited by Alton Blevins
See son Elisha Blevins-3693 profile. Added "Proof of Parental Relationships", DNA Research Notes (Family Tree), shared residency notes with father Daniel, proven brother John Blevins-1962, and brothers Richard Blevins-113, and Jonathan Blevins-195.
posted by [Living Marshall]
edited by [Living Marshall]
Once again... way to go, Ange!!! ☺️👍
posted by Day (Bredleau) Thomas
Thank you for adding those notes. I will send you a private message with some thoughts on how we can try to sort these families out.
posted by Scott McClain
Thank you to you, too, Scott, for the diligence. I know you've been of great assistance to Ange, & am so glad both of you care so much about these ancestors of ours & getting them figured out.
posted by Day (Bredleau) Thomas
Thanks Scott, the clear research notes were previously added.

The cluster group (Montgomery and Grayson) does apply to the correct son Elisha Blevins-3693 who migrates and is documented with family including father Daniel 110 (Cluster group, Montgomery records, Washington County Court Records (building of Burke roads), migration with brothers John, Jonathan and Richard into Wayne, KY.. Notes described in "Records" on his profile, which clearly defines him as the probable proven (by residency, migration) son of Daniel 110.

The other (separate identity) Elisha Blevins-2547 (for detachment) migrates with family into Ashe, North Carolina. Notes described in "Disputed Parentage" (in between an older biography / research notes) clearly define his probable parentage as James Jr., who sons migrate into Ashe, NC. These notes are found on his profile. Are there any questions before he is detached?

Two separate Elisha's born in Montgomery, Virginia in a similar time, one the son of James who migrates into Ashe, NC. The other the son of Daniel who migrates with brothers into Wayne, KY. (not conflated)

Edit note - please see comments on Elisha Blevins-2547 for detachment.

posted by [Living Marshall]
edited by [Living Marshall]
I don't agree that the research notes are clear yet and I don't understand the claim for how you believe these relationships are proven. This is a very confusing family and we need to be especially careful to avoid creating duplicates and conflated profiles. These Blevins profiles were previously full of errors on WikiTree and we need to make sure we have good sources for every claim we make, and that we cite those sources with inline citations to avoid any confusion.

You are asserting that the Elisha who is clustered with this Daniel and his sons James and John on Montgomery County tax lists is Elisha Blevins, who died in Clinton County, Illinois. What is the basis for the claim that Elisha, son of this Daniel, migrated to Illinois rather than to North Carolina? I have read the profiles, but I still don't understand what the basis for this claim is.

posted by Scott McClain
You've done an incredible job, Ange. I hope one day we will recover, or at least get some copies of, our family Bible with much genealogical history recorded & that there will be mention(s) made of the Blevins line. However, we must accept that much of our family history was either never recorded or is hard (almost impossible!) to find. You've done a remarkable job of researching & sometimes being required to "read between the lines" in order to get as close to the reality as possible. That's especially admirable considering the complications involved in this family, as Scott noted. There aren't enough thank yous for all you've done.
posted by Day (Bredleau) Thomas
There has never been a Saint George's County, Maryland. Is it Prince George's County that is intended? There is no source for the information on his birth place.
posted by Jack Day
Yes, I fixed that. It was in the Monocacy Hundred.
posted by Scott McClain
Elisha Blevins-2547 is not the son of Daniel 110 Jr. Are there any objections to detaching him for now?
posted by [Living Marshall]
Let me take a closer look at this. I can see that you have raised this an issue on the profile of Blevins-2547, but I recall that the family clustering on the tax lists for Montgomery & Grayson county suggested that he was the son of this Daniel and not James. We need to sort this out and develop a clear Research Notes discussion which lays out this conflicting evidence.
posted by Scott McClain
Daniel 3818, is the clear duplicate of Daniel Blevins-110. Before the merging process is initiated is there any questions or concerns?
posted on Blevins-3818 (merged) by [Living Marshall]
Daniel 3818 was researched as possible son of James Blevins-245 based on a previous genealogy theory. This was proven to be incorrect.

Daniel 3818 is the duplicate of Daniel Blevins-110, father is Daniel Blevins-111.

posted on Blevins-3818 (merged) by [Living Marshall]
edited by [Living Marshall]
Daniel is the duplicate of Daniel Blevins-110.
posted on Blevins-3506 (merged) by [Living Marshall]
edited by [Living Marshall]
Added sources, research notes, trying to rebuild this lineage using sourced material.
posted on Blevins-3506 (merged) by [Living Marshall]
edited by [Living Marshall]
Hi! I have added the US Southern Colonies Project and Scott McClain (Project Coordinator for the project's Managed Profiles Teams) as managers.
posted on Blevins-976 (merged) by Liz (Noland) Shifflett
And it turns out the Scott County Daniel also already has his own profile, now managed by the Virginia Project: Daniel Blevins (1775-)

Based on this, unless anyone objects, I plan to treat this profile (Blevins-110) as the "Power of Attorney" Daniel (abt 1731-aft 1797), and pull the rest of the material out of this profile to incorporate into those other profiles. They all need some clean up as well.

posted by Scott McClain
I'm confused enough as it is, and am glad Scott is so involved with the Blevins saga, so no objections. But... I repeat... I'm confused. Don't we normally merge such profiles, or are they simply too messed up? Or an unmatched merge? Carry on either way.
posted by Day (Bredleau) Thomas
edited by Day (Bredleau) Thomas
If you have two different profiles which both represent the same person, then yes, you would normally merge the profiles. However, in this case, Blevins-110 contains conflated elements of three _different_ individuals named Daniel Blevins. So in this case, we are separating those elements out into three different profiles representing each of the three separate Daniels. Two of the Daniels mixed up in this profile already have their own other profiles, so the info about those two will be removed from this profile and incorporated into the correct profile. What's left will be the cleaned up version of this profile, which will then represent only a single individual. You are right, it is confusing!
posted by Scott McClain
edited by Scott McClain
Thanks for the succinct explanation! Every time I've seen a new comment on this, it's befuddled me, but what you wrote here entirely makes sense. Commendations on all of your perseverance, Scott!
posted by Day (Bredleau) Thomas
Also, note that the "Revolutionary War Daniel" already has a WikiTree profile which is protected by the Southern Pioneers Project: Daniel Blevins (1760-1839)

That profile also needs clean up, but it clearly represents the Daniel who submitted the Rev War pension application.

posted by Scott McClain
OK, I am confident now that we have at least three different Daniels, for the reasons explained in the three parallel bios & Research Notes above. Please let me know if anyone has any comments on what I have so far.

Also, I have not found any reliable basis for any of the children claims connecting them to ANY of these Daniels. If they relate to anyone, it is probably the Scott County Daniel, but I don't see any reliable evidence to support even that. The claims all seem to have been made by Leslie Blevins based entirely upon the speculative conclusions in his own book The Longhunters. He cites no sources for the claims in his book. I have posted a heads up comment on the profiles for each of the children to see if anyone comes forward with any evidence to support those claims, and absent anything, I plan to detach them all.

posted by Scott McClain
Thank you all so much for the work you are doing on the Blevins family. I can work with census, birth, and death certificates, marriage liscense's and such, but beyond that I am still an amateur. I do have a copy of The Longhunters, and I have used Appalachian Crossroads, The Hezekiah Sellards Family, but have to travel 150 miles to reference it! I am descended from Stafford, Blevins, Castle, Daniel, and Sellards and they all have the same issue-multiple generations with large families using the same names. And of course, they all came here before the Revolutionary War and settled in that particular region of Virginia before going to Kentucky. Since my sister and I were orphaned in Ohio we had no family elders to ask, but as I have learned from Castle, Blevins, and Stafford-that can be very misleading as well! Documentation is a must! Again....Thank you so much for the untangling! Cindy Stafford Schneider
I am trying to sort out the claims in this profile, which I think may be conflating more than one Daniel Blevins. I plan to treat this profile as the one representing Daniel, the son of Daniel Blevins (abt.1712-aft.1771), i.e., the Daniel Jr. who was living in Botetourt County when he signed the 1771 POA with his father. That Daniel had to have been born in 1750 or earlier (possibly much earlier) because he had to be at least 21 when he signed the POA. If anyone is interested in collaborating with me on the effort, please weigh in. I would welcome the help -- this family is very confusing.
posted by Scott McClain
When I encounter this problem, I start by dividing the biography material into three major sections -- biography of person A, biography of person B, and Undifferentiated. Every fact gets an inline citation so that I will know how trustworthy it is. At first, most of the material is in Undifferentiated, but as the different characteristics of person A and person B emerge, it gets moved to their biographical sections. Only at the end of the process do I decide whether person A or B gets to keep the original profile, with the other getting a new one. Keeping them all on the same profile permits easily moving material back and forth as one is trying to figure things out!

Once it seemed like six different people had been conflated, but as I studied them I got them down to three. It's like the whodunit detective game where "the man with the cane is petting a cat." "the woman with the pink scarf has a red handkerchief." Etc.

posted by Jack Day
edited by Jack Day
That’s good advice- I will follow that approach. Thanks Jack.
posted by Scott McClain
This should help you...

In July 1761, John Blevins sued Daniel Dean on an attachment against Dean's estate. The recording clerk wrote "It appearing that Daniel Blevins Junr owes defendant 3 pounds, 16 shillings and 6 pence, this day came the plaintiff by Paul Carrington, his attorney, and defendant failing to replevy, plaintiff proved his account for 4 pounds, 12 shillings, and one penny. It is ordered that the sum be condemned in the hands of said Daniel Blevins, toward satisfying this debt."

This implies that Daniel Blevins Junr was born in or before 1740.

posted by Alton Blevins
Thank you! I would like to add a citation into the profile - can you let me know where I can find this record?
posted by Scott McClain
I used quotation marks so the quote came from a source document, I looked thru my research notes for my 5th Great-Grandfather John Blevins and his nephew Daniel Blevins Jr and drew blanks. I used the library back in those long ago days so if anyone wants to research the quote they should consult Halifax County, Virginia Court Orders, 1759-1762 (Plea Book No. 3). Daniel Dean (my 5th Great Grand-Uncle) was forever suing and being sued.
posted by Alton Blevins
I'm very interested in this Daniel. I've been working on Elijah who I believe was the Blevins ancestor of a high school friend, and on the Daniel of Revolutionary War pension application file S31555 -- yes, it's one man, not two. My hangup is the birth year of Daniel Jr, son of Daniel Sr, signers of the 1771 POA in their attempt to recover land in Westerly. My hang up is the birth year for Daniel Jr. The earliest I can use is "in or before 1740" which is based on a 1761 lawsuit. You use "in about 1731" -- can you tell me the source of that year?
posted by Alton Blevins
You're right, we can't really say much more than "before 1741" based on the land transactions - that's consistent with the research notes on his birth which Ange recently added to. I have adjusted the data field to reflect that.

As you can see, we have some ongoing discussion about whether we've got the correct sons attached to this man, so any insight you can share on that will be helpful.

posted by Scott McClain
We can say in or before 1740 based on a 1761 lawsuit filed my ancestor, John Blevins. From my bio for Daniel Jr: "In July 1761, John Blevins sued Daniel Dean on an attachment against Dean's estate. The recording clerk wrote "It appearing that Daniel Blevins Junr owes defendant 3 pounds, 16 shillings and 6 pence, this day came the plaintiff by Paul Carrington, his attorney, and defendant failing to replevy, plaintiff proved his account for 4 pounds, 12 shillings, and one penny. It is ordered that the sum be condemned in the hands of said Daniel Blevins, toward satisfying this debt." Daniel had to be at least 21 to be involved in a lawsuit, thus born in or before 1740. I'm satisfied with that -- an earlier date would have been nice, but unnecessary. See below for my reasoning.

I'm almost finished with my write up for Daniel's son Daniel (Revolutionary War pension file S31555). Based on the ages he gave in Rhone in 1823 and adjacent Morgan in 1834 we can say say the he was born sometime during 1752 and 1760 -- based on his 1830 Harlan County, Kentucky census record he was born sometime during 1760 and 1770 -- 1760 it is, thus a father born in or before 1740 is consistent with Mother Nature.

posted by Alton Blevins
Can you provide any source citation on that lawsuit? I would like to add a cite to it in the profile if we can.
posted by Scott McClain
When you say "it's one man, not two" -- do you mean you believe that this Daniel is the Daniel who filed pension application S31555?
posted by Scott McClain
So many Daniels, so much confusion. The first Daniel to arrive in what's now Henry County, Virginia was the Daniel who was listed with his father James in the 1733 Monocacy Hundred tax list. He was the Daniel Sr of Pittsylvania who, with his son Daniel Jr of Botetourt, gave power of attorney in 1771 to recover land in Westerly, Rhode Island. We don't know when the younger Daniel moved west to what's now Grayson County, Virginia, but it was in or before 1771 because he shows up in 1771 New River tithable list. Daniel Jr's son Daniel is the one who applied for a Revolutionary War pension, first in Rhone County, Tennessee in 1823, then in adjacent Morgan County, Tennessee in 1834. I like to call the father Daniel of 1771 Pittsylvania and his son Daniel of 1771 Botetourt. I need a nickname for the third generation Daniel.
posted by Alton Blevins
Hi! Scott McClain has been working on the Blevins family on behalf of the US Southern Colonies Project. I have added him as a manager of this profile to facilitate that work.

Cheers, Liz (co-leader, US Southern Colonies Project)

posted by Liz (Noland) Shifflett
Robert Lumpkin, son of George Lumpkin of Pittsylvania county, VA mentioned as witness to power of attorney in 1771
posted by David Douglass
Blevins of Estill KY, mninll, 28 Oct 2016
posted by David Douglass
William Blevins and Ann Bunch, Taken from "Blevin's Ancestry" by Bill Dwayne Blevins, August 1972. Bill D. Blevins, Publisher, 716 East 6th St., Mountain Home, AR.

Sorting out 3 men named William Blevins <www.ancestry,com>

posted by David Douglass
The 1790 and 1800 US census returns one HOH by tte name of James Rentfrow (see documentation in bio) residing in Wayne, North Carolina

"United States Census, 1790," database with images, FamilySearch (https://familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:XH2M-Z7H : accessed 24 January 2018), James Rentfrow, Wayne, North Carolina, United States; citing p. 471, NARA microfilm publication M637, (Washington D.C.: National Archives and Records Administration, n.d.), roll 7; FHL microfilm 568,147.

posted by David Douglass
The 1850 US census returned 44 (fourty-four) results for Daniel Blevins With three individuals born before 1800.

"United States Census, 1850," database with images, FamilySearch (https://familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:MDJX-P5X : 12 April 2016), Daniel Bliven, Westerly, Washington, Rhode Island, United States; citing family 322, NARA microfilm publication M432 (Washington, D.C.: National Archives and Records Administration, n.d.).

posted by David Douglass
In the 1840 US census there are 12 (twelve) Dnaiel Blevins with several of interest:
1.) Daniel Biven, Westerly, Washington, Rhide Island
2.) Daniel Blevins, Ashe, North Carolina
3.) Daniel Blevins, Sullivan, Tennessee

There again it is clear that these are separate persons.

posted by David Douglass
In the 1830 US census we find 9 (nine) Daniel Blevins with four of interest:
1.) Daniel Bliven, Westerly, Washington, Rhode Island
2.) Daniel Blevens, Ashe, North Carolina
3,) Daniel Blevin, Scott, Virginia
4.) [Unknown] Blevin, Blue River, Harrison, Indiana (*refer to Blevins-1920)

Again, it is clear that these are four separate individuals with similar names.

posted by David Douglass
In the 1820 US census we find 4 (four) Daniel Blevins with two of particular interest:
1.) Daniel Blevins, Scott, Virginia
2.) Daniel Blevin, Westerly, Washington, Rhode Island

This fact would seem to indicate that these are two different Daniel Blevin(s), one in Virginia and one in Rhode Island. Their relationship, if any, is unknown at present.

posted by David Douglass
The Daniel in Westerly was descended from Edward Bliven and Isabel McCoon. The Daniel in Virginia must have been descended from Edward's brother James. James has been traced from Westerly to Monocacy Hundred to Goochland to what's now Henry County, Virginia.
posted by Alton Blevins
In the 1800 US census we find 1 (one) Daniel Bliven (Blevin). This Daniel Blevin is residing at Westerly, Washington, Rhode Island, United States.

"United States Census, 1800," database with images, FamilySearch (https://familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:XHRQ-4Y2 : accessed 23 January 2018), Daniel Bliven, Westerly, Washington, Rhode Island, United States; citing p. 722, NARA microfilm publication M32, (Washington D.C.: National Archives and Records Administration, n.d.), roll 46; FHL microfilm 218,681.

Link to image of original document

posted by David Douglass
Family Search (LDS) has a profile (33FK-RMR) and Pedigree File that indicates there exists a great deal of inconsistant and contradictory information for Daniel Blevin(s) as follows:

Birth

1.) Birth: 1738, Isle of Wight, James City, VA
2.) Birth: 1753, Botecourt (note spelling), VA
3.) Birth: 1740, Isle of Wight, James City, VA
4.) Birth: about 1738, R.I., Md. or Virginia (?)
5.) Birth: From 1730 to 1740, RI, MD, or: Isle of Wight/James City/Brunswick, Virginia
6.) Birth: about 1737, Rhode Island
7.) Birth: about 1737,England (maybe Boutentout Co, VA)

Death

1.) Death: 5 September 1839, Scott, Virginia
2.) Death: ND, Rhode Island
3.) Death: about 1790, Buncombe, North Carolina
4.) Death: about 1832. Morgan, Tennessee
5.) Death: 1781,Virginia, USA,

Other

1.) 1 July 1771, Power of attorney in Va. to James Rentfrow to recover land in R.I.
2.) Marriage: Daniel Blevins (1738-1839) to Sarah Blecher (1813-1880)
3.) Father: Daniel Blevins, source: Charles E. Austin 9322 Seasons Drive Chattanooga, TN 37421-5322 (432) 855-1977
4.) Grandfather: William Blevins, source: "Pedigree Resource File," database, FamilySearch (https://familysearch.org/ark:/61903/2:2:33FK-GVZ : accessed 2018-01-23), entry for William /Blevins/.

Sources

1). Pedigree Resource File - Blevins and Lloyd family tree, Research on the Blevins family of north Alabama and Georgia, and the Lloyd family from North Carolina, Florida, and Georgia., Submitted 1/7/2014 by Steve Blevins
2.) OneWorldTree, Database online. www.ancestry.com
3.) Public Member Trees, Database online. www.ancestry.com
4.) Ancestry Family Trees, Ancestry Family Trees Ancestry.com
5.) 24635.GED.FTW
6.) World Family Tree Vol. 16, Ed. 1, Tree #0184

Clearly this Family Search Pedigree illustrates the widespread confusion and mingling of inconsistant data in regards to Daniel Blevins. It is very likely that facts and outright unsupported guesswork in regards to several individuals named Daniel Blevins are being combined into one confusing and inaccurate profile. This can only be resolved through careful sourcing and research to untangle the current mixing of biographical information.

posted by David Douglass
Blevins-1110 and Blevins-976 do not represent the same person because: different person
posted on Blevins-976 (merged) by [Living McQueen]

B  >  Blevins  >  Daniel Blevins Jr.

Categories: Virginia Colonists