In 1765, when she was probably in her mid-sixties, Margaret died of unknown causes in Orange County, Virginia .
Most of the first two generations of Catlett children in Virginia are fairly well documented, but there is a frustrating cloud of confusion over John Catlett II and Elizabeth Gaines's' daughter Margaret. No date of birth has been found, but was probably in the late 1690s or early 1700s; and no date of her marriage "late in life" to a John/Jonathan Gibson.
Neither Stubbs nor Hauk have much to offer other than the unusual bequeath Margaret's father made by passing his Green Hill estate to his seventh child and fourth daughter, provided she remain unmarried. William Fitzhugh Catlett said, "She preferred matrimony to patrimony and forfeited her right..." [1][2]
The Taylor-Gibson family tradition has it that Margaret's husband was the Jonathan Gibson of Caroline County where he was a representative in the House of Burgesses 1736-41, and clerk of Orange County in 1740; [3] but further research showed that these were two different Jonathan Gibsons, and Margaret's husband was the latter (see Jonathan Gibson, Jr.'s profile).
Another Taylor-Gibson researcher believes that Margaret's husband was the Jonathan Gibson who was sheriff of King George County and died in 1729; [4] but that was Jonathan Gibson, Sr., the father of Jonathan Gibson, Jr. whom Margaret married.
To confuse matters even further...
Margaret's niece Mary Catlett (daughter of Margaret's brother John Catlett III), married a Jonathan Gibson of King George County where he was sheriff in 1736, patented land in 1748, and served as a tobacco inspector for warehouses on the Rappahannock River; and...
Margaret's nephew John Catlett IV married Alice Gibson (d. 3/15/1761 in Orange Co.), daughter of her husband's parents, Jonathan Gibson and Elizabeth Thornton.
Further research has demonstrated with reasonable certainty that Margaret married the Jonathan Gibson, Jr. (abt. 1700-1745) who was the son of Jonathan Gibson, Sr. (abt. 1670-abt.1729) and Elizabeth Thornton (1674-1732); and that Margaret had a daughter Rachel who married Col. George Taylor of Orange County. [5][6][7]
From Findagrave.com
Margaret Catlett Gibson
Birth: 1702 Essex County, Virginia; Death: unknown; Burial: Non-Cemetery Burial. Memorial #: 93846906.
Bio: Margaret was born around 1702, the daughter of John 2nd and Mary (Gaines) Catlett of Essex (now Caroline) Co., Virginia. (Her mother is often erroneously identified as Elizabeth Gaines.) She married Jonathan Gibson 2nd ca. 1725. (His wife is often erroneously identified as Mary Catlett; Mary, Margaret's sister, in fact married John Taliaferro.) Jonathan Gibson was a burgess of Caroline County during the 1730s and then second clerk of Orange County, where they moved ca. 1740. (Bio by Mark Hale)
Family Members: Parents: John Catlett (1658-1724), Mary Gaines Catlett ( ?-?): Spouse: Jonathan Gibson (1700-1745); Siblings: John Catlett (1685-1739); Half Siblings: Rebecca Catlett Conway Unknown-1760), Elizabeth (?-?), Catlett Thornton (1689-1751), Mary Catlett Taliaferro (1691-1771), Thomas Catlett (1707-1739); Children: Jonathan Gibson (1729-1791)[8]
Sources
↑ Stubbs, Dr. & Mrs. William Carter, A History of Two Virginia Families transplanted from County Kent, England: Thomas Baytop, Tenterden, 1638 and John Catlett, Sittingbourne, 1622. Published in New Orleans, LA, 1918
↑ from Jouett Taylor Prisley and Sarah McIntosh Taylor family history and genealogy papers
↑ Boyajian, Ned. No connect. between Jonathan GIBSON and the Bishop of London?, 11 June 2005, from a now-defunct GenForum.com web site
↑ Espy, Willard R., Oysterville: Roads to Grandpa's Village, University of Washington Press, Aug 1, 1992
↑ Stubbs, Dr. & Mrs. William Carter, A History of Two Virginia Families transplanted from County Kent, England: Thomas Baytop, Tenterden, 1638 and John Catlett, Sittingbourne, 1622. Published in New Orleans, LA, 1918
Taylor, Francis Diary, 1786-1799, University of North Carolina Library
Source: S-2130033797 Repository: #R-2146549482 Title: Ancestry Family Trees Publication: Online publication - Provo, UT, USA: The Generations Network. Original data: Family Tree files submitted by Ancestry members. Note: This information comes from 1 or more individual Ancestry Family Tree files. This source citation points you to a current version of those files. Note: The owners of these tree files may have removed or changed information since this source citation was created. Page: Ancestry Family Trees Note: Data: Text: http://trees.ancestry.com/pt/AMTCitationRedir.aspx?tid=7276982&pid=218
Is Margaret your ancestor? Please don't go away! Login to collaborate or comment, or contact
the profile manager, or ask our community of genealogists a question.
Sponsored Search by Ancestry.com
DNA Connections
It may be possible to confirm family relationships with Margaret by comparing test results with other carriers of her mitochondrial DNA.
However, there are no known mtDNA test-takers in her direct maternal line.
It is likely that these autosomal DNA test-takers will share some percentage of DNA with Margaret:
SB-GedMatch M811138 Matches
Timothy Smith T729958 at 4.1cM
Linda Lowe-A387498 at 12.3 cM
Eliza Jarrett-M981133 at 7.0cM + 2 Segments,
Bob Dill-M115546 at 3.4 cM
Dick Franks-A103734 at 15.1 cM
Susan Drumm-M218124 at 4.9cM
Catlett-110 and Catlett-56 appear to represent the same person because: same person, parents, spouse....If this is not a match, please remove the spouse that is married before Catlett-56's birth.
The Margaret Catlett who married Jonathan Gibson was the daughter of John Catlett II, not John Catlett III. John Catlett III did not have a daughter Margaret by either his first wife Elizabeth Taliaferro or his second wife Mary Grayson.
SB-GedMatch M811138 Matches Timothy Smith T729958 at 4.1cM Linda Lowe-A387498 at 12.3 cM Eliza Jarrett-M981133 at 7.0cM + 2 Segments, Bob Dill-M115546 at 3.4 cM Dick Franks-A103734 at 15.1 cM Susan Drumm-M218124 at 4.9cM