John with his father and his family left Ipswich in Suffolk, their last port in England, aboard the Rose on 15 April and arrived in Boston, in the Massachusetts Bay Colony, on 8 June 1637.[1]
Marriage
"[1647] John Metcalfe & Mary Chickering, was married the 23 of the 1 mo."[3]
Medfield Activities
John settled in Medfield in 1652, just a year after the town got started. He served as selectman six years (1672, 1673, 1675, 1676, 1679, 1688), and was Commissioner in 1682.,[4]
Death
John Metcalf (Medcalfe), Sr. died 8 October, 1690 in Medfield, Suffolk, Massachusetts. [5]
NOT: "Deaths [1675] John Metcalf, deceased 27: 9: 75."[6] That seems to have been a different person, perhaps the son John born two months earlier, on 20:7:75, to Thomas and Sarah Metcalfe [7] It is clear from the probate records (see below) that this John, husband of Mary, died about 1691.
Burial
Vine Lake Cemetery, Medfield, Norfolk County, Massachusetts, USA [8]
Probate
John died intestate. The resolution of his estate took place over several years. A first distribution was made 1 March 1691 and a final settlement was agreed on 2 Dec 1697, after the decease of John's wife Mary. Distribution was made to Mary the widow, and children, John, Michael 1691 (his heirs in 1697), Elizabeth Davis 1691 (Ellice in 1697), Joseph, Experience (wife of Isaac Wheeler), Hannah (wife of Elisha Bullen), Mary (wife of Eleazer Ellice)[9]
Children
Children of John and Mary Chickering Metcalf, first three born in Dedham, Suffolk, Massachusetts:[10][11], one with a secondary source but no birth record yet found, and last four in Medfield, Suffolk, Massachusetts:[12]
John Medcalfe, b. "21 of the 1 mo.", 21 Mar 1648, bp. 16 Mar
Experience Medcalf, daughter, b. 13 Oct 1662, bp. 3 days later, married Isaac Wheeler
Hanna Medcalfe, daughter, b. 13 Oct 1664, married Elisha Bullen
Mary Medcalfe, daughter, b. 2 June 1668, married Eleazar Ellis
Sources
↑ 1.01.1 Howard Hurtig Metcalfe, Some Descendants of Rev. Leonard Metcalf of Tatterford Parish, Norfolk, England, Mostly those of his son Michael the emigrant to Dedham, Massachusetts, in 1637 (Bowie, MD: Heritage Books, 2002), p. 5; p. 4, citing Banks, "Metcalf" NEHGR 80:313
↑ Metcalf, Isaac Stevens. Metcalf genealogy. Cleveland: The Imperial press, 1898 p. 17
↑ Tilden, William Smith, The History of the Town of Medfield, Massachusetts . . . 1650 - 1886 (Boston, 1887, Geo. H. Ellis), pp. 74-102, 436
↑Vital Records of Medfield, Massachusetts to the Year 1850, (Boston: New-England Historic Genealogical Society, 1903), p. 223, listed as Medcalfe, John Sr.
↑ Don Gleason Hill, compiler, The Record of Baptisms, Marriages & Deaths ... Town of Dedham, MA, 1638-1845 (Dedham, MA: Town of Dedham, 1886), p. 15
↑ Don Gleason Hill, compiler, The Record of Baptisms, Marriages & Deaths ... Town of Dedham, MA, 1638-1845 (Dedham, MA: Town of Dedham, 1886), page 15
↑ Suffolk County, MA: Probate File Papers. Online database. AmericanAncestors.org. New England Historic Genealogical Society, 2017. #1837 (From records supplied by the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court Archives. Digitized mages provided by FamilySearch.org
https://www.americanancestors.org/DB2735/i/48697/1837-co1/0
Is John your ancestor? Please don't go away! Login to collaborate or comment, or
contact
a profile manager, or ask our community of genealogists a question.
This person immigrated to New England between 1621-1640 as a Minor Child (under age 21 at time of immigration) of a Puritan Great Migration immigrant who is profiled in Robert Charles Anderson's Great Migration Directory (or is otherwise accepted by the Puritan Great Migration (PGM) Project).
Please feel free to improve the profile(s) by providing additional information and reliable sources. PGM encourages the Profile Managers to monitor these profiles for changes; if any problems arise, please contact the PGM Project via G2G for assistance. Please note that PGM continues to manage the parent's profile, but is happy to assist on the children when needed.
I see no evidence of the last change (Birth date of Experience) Anyone got access to church records? Printed birth records say the 16th. Objections to changing back
Metcalf-208 and Metcalf-61 appear to represent the same person because: the death date difference has been solved. There is no reason to believe the birth date on the Find a grave memorial. The children listed on both profiles belong to the same person. These two should be merged.
Can someone with access to the 2002 book by Metcalfe please quote the relevant portions that may help us address the discrepancies apparently related to the duplicates?
As Deborah Hughes, Karen Harbart, David Thomson, and Bobbie Hall have suggested, Metcalf-633 and -61 profile the same person. As to the "birth" date discrepancy of 4 months, I suggest that he was born on May 15 and baptized September 5, 1622. Same parents, obviously not two separate births. As the the death date discrepancy, Medfield vital records, Tilden (page 436), and even FindAGrave all cite the 1690 date; Tilden points out that he served as commissioner in Medfield in 1682. A John Tilden did die on 27:9:(16)75, but that was in Dedham (page 15), not Medfield, and was a different person, perhaps the John born two months earlier, on 20:7:75 to Thomas and Sarah Metcalfe (Dedham, page 14).
It seems to me that Metcalfe-633 and Metcalf-61 are the same persons with conflicting birth dates and death dates. The parents are common as is the wife. What needs to be resolved is the conflict in birth date and death date. Metcalf-61 has provided superior evidence of birth and death date. The gravestone has the death date. As to the birth, the year is agreed upon. Is there no way to keep track of alternate 'facts'?
Please feel free to improve the profile(s) by providing additional information and reliable sources. PGM encourages the Profile Managers to monitor these profiles for changes; if any problems arise, please contact the PGM Project via G2G for assistance. Please note that PGM continues to manage the parent's profile, but is happy to assist on the children when needed.
So, these are the same person, please merge them!