no image
Privacy Level: Open (White)

Berthe (Ballon) of Gloucester (abt. 1070)

Berthe of Gloucester formerly Ballon aka de Pîtres
Born about in Francemap
Daughter of [father unknown] and [mother unknown]
[sibling(s) unknown]
Wife of — married 1087 in Englandmap
Descendants descendants
Died [date unknown] [location unknown]
Problems/Questions
Profile last modified | Created 12 Apr 2014
This page has been accessed 8,399 times.

Contents

Biography

Research Notes

Not the daughter of Dru de Ballon

No evidence has been found that she was the daughter of Dru de Ballon and she has been disconnected from that profile.

Charles Cawley, Foundation for Medieval Genealogy

"Walter of Gloucester married Berthe, daughter of . . . "Walterus de Gloucestria, assensu Milonis filii mei et Berthæ uxoris meæ" donated "ecclesiam de Cernay…ecclesiam… Sanctæ Helenæ de Halgestane…terram…de Westwode in Herchenefelde" to Gloucester St Peter by undated charter[328]. The Complete Peerage suggests that Berthe was a relative of Hamelin de Ballon Lord of Abergavenny, citing the passage from the Historia fundationis cum fundatoris genealogia of the priory of Abergavenny quoted above[329]. However, there are two difficulties with this hypothesis. Firstly, it is Walter, not his son, who is described as “consanguineo” of Brien FitzCount, suggesting that the relationship must have been through Walter’s parents not his wife. Secondly, doubt exists about the relationship between Brien FitzCount (generally identified as the illegitimate son of Alain IV Duke of Brittany, although the primary source which confirms that this affiliation is correct has not yet been traced) and Hamelin de Ballon, as discussed more fully in the document WALES (Lords of Abergavenny). The Complete Peerage also cites[330] the undated charter under which “Willielmus de Braosa” confirmed donations to Abergavenny Priory by “Hamelinus de Balon et Brientius comitis filius et Walterus de Herefort et Henricus de Herefort”[331]. This document does suggest a close relationship between the two families. However, a family connection through the mother of Miles of Gloucester is not the only possibility. Walter & his wife had [three] children[1]:

  • Miles of Gloucester, Earl of Hereford (d 24 Dec 1143)
  • Matilda (m. Richard FitzPons)
  • _ _ _ _ _. (Had child Renaud, d 25 Aug 1149)

Did Walter marry Emma instead?

  • Some modern sources make the spurious claim that Walter married Emma, sister of Hamelin de Balun.
This was put forward by the herald Robert Glover, apparently in an attempt to explain the association with the lordship of Abergavenny. Brian fitz Count granted the honour of Abergavenny to Miles of Gloucester between July 1141 and December 1142, Empress Matilda issuing a charter confirming the deed. Abergavenny bordered Miles’s honour of Brecknock, solidifying his base in the region. [2]

Sources

  1. http://fmg.ac/Projects/MedLands/ENGLISH%20NOBILITY%20MEDIEVAL.htm
  2. Reed, Paul C. "The Seymour Family of Hatch, Somerset, and de la Mare Family of Little Hereford" (2010) p. 229, footnote 76.
  • Weber, Jim. "The Phillips, Weber, Kirk, & Staggs families of the Pacific Northwest," RootsWeb.




Is Berthe your ancestor? Please don't go away!
 star icon Login to collaborate or comment, or
 star icon ask our community of genealogists a question.
Sponsored Search by Ancestry.com

DNA
No known carriers of Berthe's DNA have taken a DNA test.

Have you taken a DNA test? If so, login to add it. If not, see our friends at Ancestry DNA.



Comments: 12

Leave a message for others who see this profile.
There are no comments yet.
Login to post a comment.
Marriage date should be before 1085 for consistency with birth date of daughter Matilda, or change Matilda’s birth date
posted by Andrew Hill
changed the birth year of her daughter
posted by Liz (Noland) Shifflett
I have been documenting the children of Ballon-4, Dru de Ballon, who is himself is named only in one questionable source. Confirmed are Winebaud and Hameline, well documented Norman brothers. That one questionable source mentions an additional son and three daughters. In addition, three additional women were attached to Dru as daughters, with no evidence at all. Berthe is one of the latter three, so I am detaching her from Dru as her father. Berthe's actual parents are unknown.
posted by Jack Day
Ballon-3 and Pîtres-10 appear to represent the same person because: I think Emma may not have existed and should be merged with Berthe. The LNAB should probably be Unknown. If someone has research to indicate Emma existed, please let us know. Thanks.
posted on Pîtres-10 (merged) by Darlene (Athey) Athey-Hill
I think it's time for a G2G post... I'm in a remote spot on a boat with intermittent internet which will be going to non-existent in a few days. Thanks for inquiring and hope someone has answers.
Hello Darlene,

Are you managing this profile? Just curious. It's a year later.

Thanks, - Isaac

posted by Isaac Taylor
Isaac, I had thought that you would post your questions on G2G as I suggested. A quick review after this new message makes me think this profile should be merged with Berthe.

There are no people on the trusted list and thus your questions were known only to me. That is why I always suggest a post on G2G as opposed to a comment on a profile. If you have researched this person in the last year and have answers, please provide them before the merge. Thanks.

Questions after looking at this briefly:

1) Can we be more specific on her birthplace?

2) Do we have a contemporary placename? Pays-de-la-Loire is an ahistorical/modern construct.

It doesn't bode well if we don't have a source, don't know where she's from, who her parents are and we're not making progress a year after the comments below. Is it time to consider whether this is a fictional person? Or a conflation of people?

3) Is this the same Emma whom Cawley asserts is wife of Arnoul de Hesdin? Or is perhaps the later Emma who married Reginald ’fitz Count’ who d. ~1146, ie FitzRoger FitzOsbern?

4) Neverminding what Dru de Balun's name really was and how we ought to spell it... are there perhaps multiple of those (incl. earlier AND later) whom secondary sources have conflated?

posted by Isaac Taylor
See husband's article
posted on Pîtres-10 (merged) by Andrew Lancaster
https://www.academia.edu/1818131/Lost_in_Time_the_other_daughter_of_Hamelin_de_Ballon https://archive.org/details/studiesinpeerage02rounuoft/page/204 and also Keats-Rohan, do not know this person, either coming from the Ballon side or the Gloucester side.
posted by Andrew Lancaster
It may be hypothetical; he does that sometimes. Have you looked for other sources? I'm traveling overseas for two more months & not researching...
Jim Weber's website gives no source
posted by Andrew Lancaster

B  >  Ballon  |  O  >  of Gloucester  >  Berthe (Ballon) of Gloucester