There are disproven, disputed, or competing theories about this person's parents. See the text for details.
Rebecca (Short) Palmer migrated to New England during the Puritan Great Migration (1621-1640). (See Great Migration Begins, by R. C. Anderson, Vol. 3, p. 1675) Join: Puritan Great Migration Project Discuss: pgm
Rebecca was born about 1612, assuming she was about 20 when she married Walter Palmer (between her arrival in 1632 and admission to the Roxbury church June 1633).
Residence
From Roxbury, Massachusetts, church records we learn that "Rebeckah Short a maid servant, she came in the year 1632 & was married to [blank] Palmer a godly man of Charlestown church".[1]
COMMENT: Her husband was WALTER PALMER of Charlestown, Rehoboth and Stonington.[2]
The daughter Grace admitted to the church with Walter and Rebecca was a daughter of his first marriage. From his first marriage he also had children John, Elizabeth, William, and Jonah.
1633. 4:Mo:day i (1 June 1633) "walter Pamer, and Rebeckah his wife: and Grace Pamer their daughter: were Admitted." to the First Church in Charlestown.[3]
From Charlestown, the family removed to Rehoboth in 1644. Walter Palmer and his wife Rebecca were founders of Stonington, Connecticut in 1653[2]
Rebecca Palmer died at Stonington, 15 July 1671. "Saturday at night Mother palmer departed this life"[4]
Children
The children of Rebecca Short and her husband Walter Palmer were:[2]
Hannah bp 15 June 1634 (4: mo: day 15) "Hanna Palmer the daughter of Gualter Palmer and of Rebeckah his wife : was babtised."[3] m1 Thomas Hewitt, 27 Apr 1659; m2 Roger Sterry, 27 Dec 1671; m3 John Fish, 25 August 1681
Elihu bp 24 Jan 1635/6 (11th:mo:day 24) "Elihu Palmer the son of Gualter Palmer and of Rebeckah his wife was Babtised"[3] d 5 Sep 1665. unmarried.
Nehimiah bp 23 Nov 1637 (9th:mo:day 23 "Nehemiah Palmer the son of Gualter Palmer and of Rebeckah his wife was Babtised.")[3] m Hannah Stanton, 20 November 1662
Moses bp 6 April 1640 ( 2d mo day 6 "Moses Pamer the son of Gaulther Pamer and of Rebbeckah his wife was Baptized."[3] m by about 1672 Dorothy Gilbert
Benjamin bp 6 June 1642 ( 4th mo day 6 "Beniamin Palmer the son of Walter Pamer and of Rebeckah his wife was Baptized.")[3] m by 1681 an unknown wife
Gershom b. say 1644 m1 Ann Dennison, Nov 1667 m2 Elizabeth (Peck) Mason (widow of Samuel), Nov 1707
Rebecca b. say 1646 m1 Elisha Cheeseborough, 20 Apr 1665 m2 John Baldwin, 24 Jul 1672
Research Notes
Disputed Parents:Thomas Short and Ann R Short (supposedly Landum) of Cornwall were previously attached as parents, but lacked reliable sources . If sufficient evidence becomes available they can always be reconnected.
"Rebecca Short (daughter of Thomas Short. (according to research manuscripts of Dr. Byron Smith Palmer) ... (the handwritten manuscripts of Dr. Palmer have no reference.)"[5]
Estimated Birth Date: An estimated birth of 1589, used by Find A grave (at some time) was based on Walter's estimated birth. 1589 is way to early for this Walter's second wife who was having children in 1634- 1647. When sources are lacking for a more perfect estimate, the PGM Project uses an assumed age of 20 at marriage for women.
Profile Needs: (as of 1/2/24) Death dates for the children could be added but need to be researched and sourced with reliable sources first (current attached profiles contain unverified information: Hannah d 1681, Nehemiah d 1717, John d 1709, Moses d 1701, Benjamin d 1716; Gershom d 1718, Rebecca d 1713)
Errors in print:
The Walter Palmer Society records Rebecca's death as "shortly before June 5 1684" because that was when the division, by sons Nehemiah, Moses and Benjamin, of land occurred on that date which "our father left for our mother to divide".
Colonial Families of the United States of America: Volume 3 page 377 records this wife as "Esther", parents of Nehemiah.
↑ 2.02.12.2 The Great Migration Begins: Immigrants to New England 1620-1633, Volumes I-III. (Online database: AmericanAncestors.org, New England Historic Genealogical Society, 2010), (Originally Published as: New England Historic Genealogical Society. Robert Charles Anderson, The Great Migration Begins: Immigrants to New England 1620-1633, Volumes I-III, 3 vols., 1995).
https://www.americanancestors.org/DB393/i/12107/1675/0
↑ Buys, Doris Palmer. Walter Palmer of Charlestown and Rehoboth, Massachusetts and Stonington, Connecticut : a 400-year (1585-1985) family history. (Orem, Utah : Published for the compiler by Historical Publications, 1986) p 47. see also #30 and 31 on p. 46.
The Great Migration Begins: Immigrants to New England 1620-1633, Volumes I-III. (Online database: AmericanAncestors.org, New England Historic Genealogical Society, 2010), (Originally Published as: New England Historic Genealogical Society. Robert Charles Anderson, The Great Migration Begins: Immigrants to New England 1620-1633, Volumes I-III, 3 vols., 1995). p. 1675. Featured Sketch: Elizabeth Short.subscription site$
The Great Migration Begins: Immigrants to New England 1620-1633, Volumes I-III. (Online database: AmericanAncestors.org, New England Historic Genealogical Society, 2010), (Originally Published as: New England Historic Genealogical Society. Robert Charles Anderson, The Great Migration Begins: Immigrants to New England 1620-1633, Volumes I-III, 3 vols., 1995). p. 1381. Featured Sketch: Walter Palmer.subscription site$
Buys, Doris Palmer. Walter Palmer of Charlestown and Rehoboth, Massachusetts and Stonington, Connecticut : a 400-year (1585-1985) family history (1986)
Early Families of New England (New England Historic Genealogical Society, 2013) Alicia Crane Williams, Lead Genealogist. Membership required. :
History of Stonington CT, by Wheeler, page 506.
Nancy Ann Norman. Some Descendants of Walter PALMER Publication: http://freepages.genealogy.rootsweb.com/~nanc/palmer/index.htm#TOC; NOTESource Medium: Electronic Her sources: WALTER PALMER OF CHARLESTOWN AND REHOBOTH, MA & STONINGTON CT, a 400-Year (1585-1985) Family History, Compiled, Edited, Typed and Partly Researched by Doris Palmer Buys. To America 1628/9 on the "Four Sisters" AMERICAN ANCESTRY - Vol. XI (1898) by Joel Munsell's Sons. THE GRANBERRY FAMILY by Donald Jacobus (1945) GENEALOGICAL & FAMILY HISTORY OF THE STATE OF CT. by William Cutter, EXTINCT PEERAGES by Burke (1831) . THE PIONEERS OF MASSACHUSETTS by Charles Pope. NEW England REGISTER - Vol. (1857) . THE PALMERS. HISTORY OF THE FIRST CONGREGATIONAL CHURCH OF STONINGTON, CT 1674-1874" By Richard Wheeler (1875) HISTORY OF THE TOWN OF STONINGTON by Richard A. Wheeler. HISTORY OF NEW LONDON by Frances M. Caulins (1860). REGISTER OF PEDIGREES Edited by John Reynolds Totten. THE COMPENDIUM OF AMERICAN GENEALOGY - Vol. by Frederick Virkus STONINGTON CHRONOGOGY 1649-1949 -By William Haynes. COLONIAL FAMILIES OF THE UNITED STATES - by George MacKenzie. CAR-DEL SCRIBE. HISTORY OF NEW LONDON COUNTY, CT" by D. Hamilton Hurd. GENEALOGICAL DICT. OF THE FIRST SETTLERS OF NEW England by James Savage GENEALOGY OF THE DESCENDANTS OF WILLIAM CHEESEBROUGH OF BOSTON, REBOBOTH, MA by Anna Chesebrough Wildey. GENEALOGICAL GLEANINGS IN England. PALMER RECORDS by Noyes F. Palmer (1881) ELDRED AND ASSOCIATED FAMILIES, Researched by: Catherine Matson & Clarice McNiven, Compiled by: Carol & Susan Matson.
Walter Palmer Society, maintained by Katharine Palmer Smith found on The Walter Palmer website which covers the genealogy of the first eight generations of Walter Palmer. Retrieved from: (Archived site from 15 August 2015)
Find A Grave: Memorial #63161739 Wequetequock Burial Ground Stonington. No stone, but husbands stone is there.
Various shared family trees and other sources compiled on Ancestry.com. Facts & details to be added after tree input.
Is Rebecca your ancestor? Please don't go away! Login to collaborate or comment, or
contact
a profile manager, or ask our community of genealogists a question.
Conjecture under the heading "Notes" is clearly erroneous, being contradicted by the Diary of Thomas Minor (date of Rebecca's death) and Nehemiah's baptism record (Charlestown church record). I suggest removing the "Notes" section (and keep Research Notes). Also, the manuscripts of Dr. Byron S. Palmer weren't published.
I've removed the parents disputed back in 2018. Research notes with reciprocal links on all profiles are in place. If any evidence comes to light that they are the correct parents, they can always be reconnected.
Patricia, there is no justification for keeping them. If you take the time to look at the sources you will see there are none which support the identification, and they are in fact impossible with dates which don't fit (though they have been changed to try and make them fit), from impossible county connections in England. It is classic connect random people with the same name and pure internet junk.
If I am wrong, please provide a source which connects this person about whom absolutely nothing is known to any actual person in England.
Absolutely nothing is known of Rebecca Short other than the note in Roxbury church records that she came in 1632 and married [Walter ] Palmer. The parents are clearly incorrect.
Steve, please provide a source that these parents are even possibly the parents of Rebecca Short. The fact that dates have been manipulated to make connections work is a clear indication they are wrong.
When it comes to Great Migration immigrants, we must have a source for parents. This will not make wikitree fall apart, it will make it immensely more accurate.
I object to disconnections merely due lack of proof. I would prefer to see proof of different parents or proof that these parents can't be hers. If we disconnected everything without proof, WT would fall apart. I would prefer to simply mark these parents as "uncertain".
Short-2529 and Short-27 appear to represent the same person because: same husband and son, dates are unsupported on Short-2529, please use data on Short-27
If I am wrong, please provide a source which connects this person about whom absolutely nothing is known to any actual person in England.
When it comes to Great Migration immigrants, we must have a source for parents. This will not make wikitree fall apart, it will make it immensely more accurate.
Anything in the gedcom that is already in the bio (or you add to the bio) can be deleted.
If any PM has a subscripton to American Ancestors, I included two links to Great Migration Begins.
Good luck and have fun! :-)