Primary sources are lacking to document the ancestry and birth of John Stacy. It is not until his 1723 marriage in Andover, MA and the birth of his children in Killingly, Windham County, Connecticut that we have robust documentation of his life.
According to a web blog on the founders of Stacyville, Iowa, he was born about 1700 to Mark Stacy (born in Marblehead, MA).[1][2][3]
The location of his birth is uncertain.
Marriage in Andover followed by a move to Killingly, CT
On 24 January 1723 "John Stacy of Hampton" married "Sarah Preston of Andover" in Andover, Essex County, MA.[4][5][6] Refer to the section below on disambiguation of the Sarah Preston's born in Andover.
Note that there is no Hampton, MA and Hampton, Windham County, CT was not incorporated until 1786. Thus, John was probably from Hampton, New Hampshire (about 15 miles northeast of Andover) which was founded in 1638.
Records of subsequent births of their children show that, once married, Sarah and John Stacy moved to Killingly, Windham County, Connecticut.
At least 3 of Sarah's relatives moved to Windham County, Connecticut. Sarah's grandfather's brother John Preston (1685-1733) was recorded as being one of the early settlers of Hampton, Connecticut.[7] along with his brother Jacob Preston (1680-1742)[8]. John Preston may have first settled in Killingly. A land deed shows that in 1707 John Preston "of Killingly" bought 50 acres of land in Killingly.[9] In additiion, a 2014 genealogical history by Adrienne Boaz documents that two of Sarah Preston's siblings (Levi Preston (1696-1781), Jemima Preston (1701-1789) and Joanna (Preston) Utter (1702-abt.1756)) moved to Killingly.[10] Killingly was first laid out in 1708.[11]. The land was "owned by the colony of Connecticut and not by individuals or companies, and tracts of it were given by the government in recognition of civil or military services rendered it." It is possible that several members of the extended Preston family took advantage of land granted to John Preston following his service during the Naragansett War of 1670-1675.
A move to Sturbridge, MA where more children were born
By 1735 the family had moved to Sturbridge, Massachusetts (30 miles to the north of Windham) where records of all subsequent births and marriages of members of the family are to be found. Why did the family abandon Killingly?
There in Sturbridge, John and Sarah had three daughters:[17]
In 1738, John bought land in Sturbridge that had once belonged to Capt. Jonas Houghton from Henry Hucker.[18] In 1740 and 1741, he sold this land to Moses Mercy of Sturbridge.[19][20]
In 1742, John bought 22 areas of land in Sturbridge that was being sold by the town for delinquent taxes and once belonged to David Ellis.[21]
In 1744, Edward Broomfield of Boston was awarded a judgment against John Stacy who apparently "unjustly withheld, put out or moved the said Edward a field from his possession" of 172 acres of land. John was to be sent to the goal until he made payment. Payment was made on 23 August 1744.[22]
Death
A record of John's death has yet to be found. He and Sarah were likely living in Sturbridge at the time, but the Sturbridge vital records did not capture the event.[23]
According to a web blog on the founders of Stacyville, Iowa, he died about 1746.[24][25][26]
According to a 19th-century Morse family genealogical history, on 20 Oct 1762 "Mrs. Sarah, widow of John Stacy" re-married the widower Joseph Morse in Sturbridge. Sarah died in 1793.[27]
Probate
John Stacy of Sturbridge, husbandman died intestate and on 25 October 1746, his widow Sarah was granted the administration of his estate.[28] His inventory was taken on 4 November 1746 in Sturbridge which included 22 acres of land.[29][30]
In 1746, his widow Sarah was appointed guardian of his minor children, Isaac, aged 15 years, and Caleb, aged 17 years.[31]
Estate Notice 1747
In 1747, an account of his estate by his widow Sarah was recorded which included debts that were uncertain, appraisers, allowance to the widow to keep house, taxes, and administration fees.[32]
In 1748, a further account of his estate was recorded which included the balance of the last account, the commission of insolvency, and administration fees. The balance of the estate was divided among the children.[33]
Disambiguation of the 3 Sarah Preston's born in Andover
At least three Sarah's were born to members of the Preston families of Andover during this period. The first of these was born to John Preston and the second and third Sarah's were born to Samuel Preston, Jr, a nephew of John Preston.
A primary source documents the first two of these births on the same page:[34]
There was a Sarah born 5 Feb 1695 to John and Sarah (Gary) Preston. Of this Sarah, the 1918 Gary Genealogy[35] notes that her father John Preston saw action in the Narragansett War of 1670 - 1675 and subsequently moved his family to Windham County, Connecticut. According to a 19th century history of Windham County, John Preston was among the early settlers of Hampton, Windham County, Connecticut[36] which was then called Kennedy or Windham Village. As discussed below, the three sons of John and Sarah (Preston) Stacy were born in Killingly, Windham County, CT -- 15 miles to the east of Hampton. It is thus tempting to conclude that the father of Sarah (Preston) Stacy was this John Preston. However, both the Gary Genealogy and the undated manuscript entitled "The Prestons of Andover"[37] record that Sarah the daughter of John Preston died in 1712 -- prior to the 1723 marrage of John Stacy and Sarah Preston.
There was a Sarah born 26 Feb 1695, the first-born child of Samuel and Sarah (Bridges) Preston". The Prestons of Andover" records that "John Stacy of Hampton, Conn." (his residence as recorded on a marrage record[38][39]) married this Sarah Preston born in 1695. However, as noted above, this is not consistent with the 1717 probate record for Samuel Preston's estate which names Sarah as the fourth rather then the oldest of his surviving daugthers. According to a 1931 Preston family genealogical history[40] the Sarah Preston born in 1695 to Samuel and Sarah Preston (their first-born child) died 16 Aug 1703.
According to this 1931 Preston family genealogical history, another daughter born after 16 Aug 1703 was also given the name Sarah and it is this third Sarah Preston who was named in Samuel's probate record and who married "John Stacy of Hampton".
Sources
↑ The Stacy Family -- Founders of Stacyville, Iowa (http://www.videoportraits.com/Papermoon/sville/stacyfam/skhstacy.html#Gen) "4. Genealogy and Descendents of the Stacys -- Homer I. Stacy was born in DeKalb, St. Lawrence Co., NY on January 9th, 1820. His parents were Isaac (b 25 Mar 1790 in Cooperstown, NY; d 23 March 1859 in DeKalb, St. Lawrence Co.,NY) and Orp(h)a Page (b 15 May 1797 Coventry, CT, died 29 June 1873 in Princeton, Bureau Co., Illinois) Stacy. Homer was the oldest son of six children. His grandparents were: Isaac Stacy (b 17 Jan 1755 in Sturbridge, MA; d 1829 in DeKalb, NY) and Abigail Averill (b 6 June 1780 in Palmer, MA). His g-grandparents were Isaac Stacy (b 15 Mar 1730/1 in Killingly, CT) and Elizabeth Bond. His gg-grandparents were: John Stacy (born about 1700; d 1746) and wife Sarah Preston (born Feb 1694/95 in Andover, MA). His ggg-grandfather was: Mark Stacy (born about 1657 in Marblehead, MA). His gggg-grandfather was John Stacy (born about 1629 ; died June 1669 in Marblehead, MA). his ggggg-grandparents were Hugh Stacy (born about 1594 in England) and wife Margaret."
↑ "Massachusetts, Town Clerk, Vital and Town Records, 1626-2001," database with images, FamilySearch (https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:QPZC-M9RP : 19 April 2021), John Stacy and Sarah Preston, 24 Jan 1724; citing Marriage, Andover, Essex, Massachusetts Bay Colony, British Colonial America, Massachusetts Secretary of the Commonwealth, Boston; FHL microfilm 007010678.
↑ The Stacy Family -- Founders of Stacyville, Iowa (http://www.videoportraits.com/Papermoon/sville/stacyfam/skhstacy.html#Gen) "4. Genealogy and Descendents of the Stacys -- Homer I. Stacy was born in DeKalb, St. Lawrence Co., NY on January 9th, 1820. His parents were Isaac (b 25 Mar 1790 in Cooperstown, NY; d 23 March 1859 in DeKalb, St. Lawrence Co.,NY) and Orp(h)a Page (b 15 May 1797 Coventry, CT, died 29 June 1873 in Princeton, Bureau Co., Illinois) Stacy. Homer was the oldest son of six children. His grandparents were: Isaac Stacy (b 17 Jan 1755 in Sturbridge, MA; d 1829 in DeKalb, NY) and Abigail Averill (b 6 June 1780 in Palmer, MA). His g-grandparents were Isaac Stacy (b 15 Mar 1730/1 in Killingly, CT) and Elizabeth Bond. His gg-grandparents were: John Stacy (born about 1700; d 1746) and wife Sarah Preston (born Feb 1694/95 in Andover, MA). His ggg-grandfather was: Mark Stacy (born about 1657 in Marblehead, MA). His gggg-grandfather was John Stacy (born about 1629 ; died June 1669 in Marblehead, MA). his ggggg-grandparents were Hugh Stacy (born about 1594 in England) and wife Margaret."
↑ Probate estate files - Series A, case no. 55405-55485, Spurr, John W. - Staples, Elizabeth A., ca. 1731-1881, Family Search (https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:3Q9M-C9BZ-K9SP-W : 6 March 2024), Film#101285694, Worcester, Massachusetts, File# 55424, Images 243-252.
Is John your ancestor? Please don't go away! Login to collaborate or comment, or contact
the profile manager, or ask our community of genealogists a question.
Sponsored Search by Ancestry.com
DNA Connections
It may be possible to confirm family relationships with John by comparing test results with other carriers of his Y-chromosome or his mother's mitochondrial DNA.
However, there are no known yDNA or mtDNA test-takers in his direct paternal or maternal line.
It is likely that these autosomal DNA test-takers will share some percentage of DNA with John: