Contents |
ps. After writing all of this biography I discovered another profile for John Witt written by a cousin. John Witt (abt.1617-abt.1676) We have both spent an enormous amount of time in our research efforts so to satisfy the requirements of WikiTree we will need to "negotiate." You can find this other profile by looking at the merge section of this profile all of the way at the bottom.
There is considerable debate about John Witt's origins. Claims have been made of England, France, Holland and Massachusetts.
When John Witt arrived in Massachusetts is unclear. He is not listed as a member of one of the Pilgrim ships. Over 250 ships were involved with over 7000 families, but there are several ships about which no passenger list is available.
Ref 1: Pilgrims [2]
He emigrated about 1643 according to Torrey's estimate of marriage that year; or 1646 or 1650.
Ref 2: ESTIMATE [3]
He most likely arrived before 1650 because the attached map of Lynn, Massachusetts shows the location of his home in 1650.
Ref 3: Home in Lynn [4]
Another theory suggests that there were Huguenots in France named DeWitt, who fled to England during the persecution of Huguenots by the Catholic Church in the late 1500s and early 1600s. They changed their name to Witt in England. They then sailed to America in the early 1600s and their descendants changed the family name back to DeWitt in the late 1700-mid 1800s. The attached link provides historical information about the French Huguenots when many migrated to England. No mention of any DeWitt or Witt has been found.
Ref 4: History of Hugenots in England[5]
Note also, that unlike the Dutch DeWitts of New York, this Witt family includes no descendants with Dutch names.
1943
One of the most recent but 80 year old descriptions of John Witt and his descendants was published in 1943 by Frank Balcomb. The only information about John Witt's origins is: John Witt, was at Lynn by 1640, died there in Dec.1675.
Ref 5: Balcomb Book [6]
Also:
Ref 6: [7]
I have seen commentaries about the book in recent times that it is not reliable because it has many errors. Let's reflect on the effort. At that time, resources were very difficult to access. Let's appreciate that situation in the wonderful time of internet access to historical records. As a genealogist I have processed every single line of his text and checked it against other sources. I appreciate it for a skeleton upon which one can build a family history. For what it is worth the link is found at the end of the previous paragraph.
1914
In William Cutter's 'New England Families, Vol. III, Genealogies and Memorials' , there is a discussion of the New England Witt family origins. It casts doubt on a Holland origin because there were no Dutch speaking Witts in early New England, so the suggestion is that the Witts came from England. Also it is admitted that Dewitts from Holland perhaps went to England and dropped the De, or that the Witts were simply Witts which is derived from White.
Ref 7: Cutter Volume III [8]
1913
Mr. Cutter publish another genealogical book that included information about the Witt Family in 1913.
Ref 8: New ENGLAND FAMILIES VOL III [9]
He started out his discussion about the Witt Family:
Commentary:
Paragraph 1: The conjecture that the Massachusetts 1600s Witt family was of Dutch descent and distantly related to the New York Tjerck DeWitt family has been a common hypothesis. Indeed the author of this biography began his research in the 1980s about the ancestors of his 5th great grandfather John DeWitt 1758-1820 with the hypothesis that we were related to the NY Dutch DeWitts. His research with analyzing his Y-chromosome DNA is described below. The results do NOT support Mr. cutter's conjecture.
Paragraph 2: One can see that this history of John Witt of Lynn Massachusetts has been repeated over and over again. It appears to be incomplete.
1889
Another source of Witt Family information comes from one of the families that interacted with the Witt family in a land sale in Lynn, Massachusetts. In February 1772, Spinster Ruth Driver sold half of her house and land to Thomas Witt who was a grandson of John Witt (1617-1675) The house was formerly owned by her uncle Robert Driver. If you examine the Image 1 map of Lynn, Massachusetts you may notice that R. Driver ( Robert Driver) owned the house just down the road from John Witt in 1650. So the Witts and Drivers were neighbors.
Ref 9: Driver Family: [10]
Ref 10: Driver and Witt Familes: [11]
1887
The oldest discussion of the Witt Family has been found in the 1887 issue of "A genealogical register of North Brookfield families, including the records of many early settlers of Brookfield," by Charles Adams, Jr.".
Ref 11: Adams Book. [12]
In this book Mr Adams wrote about John Witt:
Nothing new was offered except for the publication date showing the interest in this family since the late 1800s.
Some claims hold that the father of John was Jacob Witt born in England in 1586 and passing away in Mass. in 1617 with an unknown mother.
Ref 12: Father of John Witt [13]
Other than opinions like the ancestral tree offered in the Reference's website this author has not found any concrete documentation about a father or mother of John Witt.
As shown in Image 1 below, his family lived on Shepard St. (See center area below the "Commons".)
Image 1: J Witt and R Driver homes in 1650. Closeup from Image 2: 1829 map of Lynn, Mass. |
It is claimed that John Witt Sr. had two wives:
Commentary: This list was present when the editor began this rewrite. He is now searching for verification of each child. some have been listed by the previous authors discussed above. However, Joshua Witt (bc1650) is a surprise.
In general, many researchers consider John Witt to be the first of this Witt family in North America. However the claim that his father named Jacob died in Massachusetts in the subsection above would then suggest the Jacob was the first Witt in America.
Several of John Witt's descendants changed their name from Witt to DeWitt so many DeWitts may claim him as their most distant known ancestor as well as many Witts.
If one reads the estate inventory of John Witt his death date of 2 Dec 1675 is stated. (See below.) If he died in Lynn, Mass in 1675 he may have been buried in the Old Burying Ground in Lynn. Unfortunately, the oldest known grave was from 1698. It should be noted that about 15 of John Witt's descendants ere buried there.
Ref 13: John's Death Date [14]
Ref 14: Old Burying Ground: [15]
Image 3: Witt/DeWitt Y-DNA Research Group Summary |
Ref 18: Y-STR Matches with Witts and DeWitts [19]
Miscellaneous: THESE NEED TO BE EVALUATED
Also there is useful info in the memories that need evaluation.
EDITOR Does anyone know why these people have been acknowledged?
John WITT John, Dec. __, 1675, P.R. 4.
Death Lynn, MA SOURCE: New England Historic Genealogical Society
A John Witt is among those petitioning the court of Boston for a plantation at Groton, 25 May, 1655. NEHGR 14:48 "The Petition for Groton Plantation." He was among those chosen as Selectman for two years. He was thus at least 21 years of age.
Torrey P. 832 says ____ 1st wife, married about 1638. 2nd wfe Sarah ____, before 1643 in Lynn/Groton.
NEHGR 141:20: "Sarah, widow of John Witt," discusses the family and his will of Sept 12, 1675, in which he mentions wife Sarah, daughter Sarah, who "presumably" was by then married, as among the heirs. Sarah is referred to as the "now mother" of John and Thomas, indicating they they were of his first marriage, however this distinction was not applied to Sarah. Widow Sarah is later found to be living in Wenham with her daughter Mary, who married Samuel Kimball.
John is noted (NEHGR 5:342 "Genealogical Items Relating to Lynn, Mass." as having wife Sarah, and Children being born noted as Martha, 1659, Thomas, 1651, Ebenezer, 1665. Another John (apparently his son--see marriage notes) marries Elizabeth Baker in 1676 and has children noted as Elizabeth, John and Mary. There are, in fact, no Sarah's listed for any of the Witts for Lynn in this brief excerpt. A Jonathan is there, as well as Joshua, indented under John and Elizabeth.
In an Ayres genealogy NEHGR 17:310, An Elizabeth Witt, dau. of John Witt marries in 1703, John Goodale(3) of Brookfield.
He was married to Sarah UNKNOWN 2nd wfe after 1651/52 in Lynn MA ?. (3429)(3430) (3431) The marriage date is a placekeeper to tentatively track descendants and purely speculative. Sarah is noted by Torrey as being second wife. John's will suggest that John and Thomas were of his first marriage. Thus Thomas, stated to be born in 1651, suggests a second marriage after this date.
Hudson's History of Marlboro P473-4) gives John Witt as in Lynn in 1640, and having two wives, noting that his record of the Witt family are very "imperfect."
He further notes that he had several daughters and at least two sons, John and Thomas. He also says John Jr. marries Elizabeth Baker in Lynn, adding that some of his children are not recorded. Those included are Elizabeth, 1677, John, June 3, 1679 (m. Mary (Handwritten in is Dane)) Jonathan, Samuel, Mary and last mentioned Thomas. This family seems about right for Sarah who marries Ephraim Potter.
The John Witt who came to Marlboro, above and who marries Mary Dane?, came to Marlboro about 1707, left a will proved May 16, 1743 which mentions wife Mary, sons William, Elias, Joseph, John, Ebenezer, dau. Mary Dike, dau. Elizabeth, and grand dau. Rebecca Goodale. Children were: John WITT Jr (P), Thomas WITT, Sarah WITT, Mary WITT.
He was married to Unknown UNKNOWN about 1638 in Lynn, MA.(3432)
SOURCE: mayflowerfamilies.com
1539. Mrs. Sarah Rooles, born 1616 in Massachusetts; died 1680 in Massachusetts.
Children of John Witt and Sarah Rooles are: 769 i. Anne Witt, born 1637 in Lynn, Essex Co., Massachusetts; died March 17, 1700/01 in Rehoboth, Bristol Co., Massachusetts; married Jr. Jacob Barney April 26, 1660 in Salem, Essex Co., Mass.. ii. Jonathon Witt, born 1638. iii. Elizabeth Witt, born Abt. 1639. iv. Mary Witt, born Abt. 1643. v. John Witt, born Abt. 1651. vi. Sarah Witt, born Abt. 1655. vii. Martha Witt, born March 05, 1658/59. viii. Thomas Witt, born July 25, 1661. ix. Ebenezer Witt, born April 06, 1665. SOURCE: Family Tree Maker Genealogy/Ancestors of Jeffery Thomas Shrout
JOHN WITT 1612-1675 [Ancestral Link: Lura Minnie Parker (Stagge), daughter of Minnie May Elmer (Parker), daughter of Mark Alfred Elmer, son of Hannah Polina Child (Elmer), daughter of Polly Barber (Child), daughter of Ichabod Barber, son of Mary Barney (Barber), daughter of Israel Barney, son of Israel Barney, son of Ann Witt (Barney), daughter of John Witt.]
In Salem, Essex County Massachusetts, John Witt first made his mark in America. He is known to have resided in Lynn, Massachusetts and was perhaps a selectman that helped organize the town Government of Groton, MS in 1655 however returning to Lynn. He was married in England and came to America with at least 5 children. The last 3 children were born to his 2nd wife Sarah in Lynn. His will dated September 12, 1675 lists his widow Sarah, and children: Ann Barney, Elizabeth, Sarah, Mary, Martha, John, Thomas and Jonathan. John died December 2, 1675. His first wife's name could not be found.
Children: ANN (ANNA), born ca. 1642 Jonathan, born ca. 1643 Elizabeth, born ca. 1645 Sarah, born ca. 1647 Mary, born ca. 1649 John, born ca. 1651/2 Martha, born Mar. 5, 1659> Thomas, born July 25. 1661 Ebenezer, born April. 6, 1665, died young ANN WITT, born in England, ca. 1642, died February 12, 1683, married May 26, 1660 to Jacob Barney Jr., born 1634 Salem, Essex County, Massachusetts, died 1692/3. found on ancestry.com
Cider and Apples: The Legacy of John and John Witt 22 April 1667 and November 1667, Essex County, Massachusetts Sometimes it is difficult to find details about ancestors, other times, the information one finds is a real eye roller, as is the story of John Witt, Sr. and John Witt, Jr., and Junior's passion for apples--or is that cider?
In Records and Files of the Quarterly Essex County Court, Witt v Croft takes up nearly a page and a half. It seems that John Junior was accused by Mistress Anne Croft of drinking up her cider on the Sabbath while she was at Meeting. John Senior took offense and sued William Croft for his wife's accusations. The case stated that Mistress Croft claimed "John Witt, jr., was a thief, had stolen her cider and drunk it on the Lord's day in time of exercise."
The case was tried on 22 April 1667. During testimony, Phillip Kartland, a servant in the Croft house, said that John Junior and friends visited when Mr. Croft was at meeting, spending their time roasting apples and drinking cider. Phillip also said that John Junior threaten to have him whipped at a post, so he dared not tell John Senior. Another servant, Timothy Cooper confirmed that John Junior and friends were in his master's house, and that Samuel More "came in on the Lord's day in the time of God's holy worship and gathered damsons and there were other boys outside who called to him to bring them good store."
Elizabeth Whiting testified that as she went to meeting with her daughter Hubbard and maid Elizabeth Barrett, she "saw the men standing suspiciously at the Croft's house," and told them they "ought to go to the meeting."
Mistress Croft, when she heard her cider was drunk, took her maid "up into the chamber" to determine who was responsible; the maid "cried and knelt down and prayed her to forgive her," and told Mistress Croft that when she had made the door fast, "Ephram Hall climbed up on a post, opened the casement, and called to let him in."
The jury found for the defendant and charged John Witt Senior one pound, sixteen shillings. The Court did not accept the verdict.
The legal case seemed to have little impact on John Junior and friends. In November of the same year, Nathanyell Kirkland, John Witt, and Ephriam Hill were were "admonished for profaning the Lord's day by going to the house of William Crofts in time of public exercise and drinking cider." ___________________________________________ SOURCE Dow, George Francis. Records and Files of the Quarterly Courts of Essex County, Massachusetts. Essex Institute. 1913. Page 422-423. http://books.google.com/books?id=Qh44AAAAIAAJ found on ancestry.com
Children: ANN (ANNA), born ca. 1642 Jonathan, born ca. 1643 Elizabeth, born ca. 1645 Sarah, born ca. 1647 Mary, born ca. 1649 John, born ca. 1651/2 Martha, born Mar. 5, 1659> Thomas, born July 25. 1661 Ebenezer, born April. 6, 1665, died young ANN WITT, born in England, ca. 1642, died February 12, 1683, married May 26, 1660 to Jacob Barney Jr., born 1634 Salem, Essex County, Massachusetts, died 1692/3. found on ancestry.com SOURCE: Stagge-Parker Histories John Witt 1612-1675
Have you taken a DNA test? If so, login to add it. If not, see our friends at Ancestry DNA.
Featured National Park champion connections: John is 12 degrees from Theodore Roosevelt, 20 degrees from Stephanus Johannes Paulus Kruger, 10 degrees from George Catlin, 13 degrees from Marjory Douglas, 22 degrees from Sueko Embrey, 9 degrees from George Grinnell, 23 degrees from Anton Kröller, 13 degrees from Stephen Mather, 20 degrees from Kara McKean, 12 degrees from John Muir, 14 degrees from Victoria Hanover and 24 degrees from Charles Young on our single family tree. Login to find your connection.
John WITT John, Dec. __, 1675, P.R. 4.
Death Lynn, MA SOURCE: New England Historic Genealogical Society