I would say Eliza Jane died between 1855 and1860 in Alabama, JMO. Didn't find her listed on Find a Grave in Hutto Cemetery.
David remarried in Sep 1860 and died and is buried in hutto cemetery, Henry Co, AL
Name: David Hutto
Gender: Male
Marriage Date: 23 Sep 1860
Marriage Place: Henry, Alabama, USA
Spouse: Sarah J. Miller
Film Number: 001288501
1870
Name: David Hutto
Gender: Male
Marriage Date: 23 Sep 1860
Marriage Place: Henry, Alabama, USA
Spouse: Sarah J. Miller
Film Number: 001288501
He married a third time in 1874, Joanna(Ann) Gassett