Comparing relationships-How does this make sense?

+3 votes
147 views
Comparing Stewart-588 and a few of his children to Fulford-387. He is said to be my 17th great grandfather. His daughters Stewart-1163 and -2306 say great aunt and 16th great grandmother. So how can his son-and their brother- Stewart-2313 be my 3rd cousin 14x removed? Your great grandfathers child is not your 3rd cousin. I have been out working in the sun but...?
in The Tree House by Anonymous Fulford G2G2 (2.3k points)

2 Answers

+5 votes
 
Best answer

Hello Samuel.

That is because "Relationship Finder" looks for the MRCA shared by both people.

1. Relationship between you and Stewart-1163

Your MRCA is your 17th great grandfather James IV Stewart.

2. Relationship between you and Stewart-2313

Your MRCA is your 16th great grandmother Margaret (Beauchamp) Welles (one generation closer to you than James IV Stewart).

Stewart-1163 and Steward-2313 are father-only siblings, their mothers are different. Relationship 1 is through your mother (to Stewart-1163's father).

Relationship 2 is through your father and Stewart-2313's mother. If you (temporarilly) detach your father's profile from you, relationship 2 will show exactly the same path shown in relationship 1.

by Rubén Hernández G2G6 Pilot (706k points)
selected by Susan Laursen

The relationship between your mother and Stewart-1163 and the relationship between your mother and Stewart-2313 are exactly the same, your mother is the 15th great grandniece of both of them.

Correct. I am 16th great grand nephew of Stewart-2313. I should not show up as his 3rd cousin...his sister is my 16 great grandmother Stewart-2306. Margaret Stewart Drummond. Thus my confusion about 3rd cousin being deemed closer than great uncle
Ruben, thank you for looking into my family with me. I appreciate it.
You are welcome, Samuel.
+4 votes

It's because it gives the closest relationship to you if there is more than one way you are related to that person. You are related to Stewart-2313 in many ways. If you look at the box below on the left where it says "Explore more" it gives a list of 320 common ancestors including his father James IV Stewart (Stewart-588) where that relationship would be 16th great grand uncle to yourself. (Although as it says in the box "Note that the relationship name will not change.")

by Samantha Thomson G2G6 Pilot (111k points)
It should say the closest relationship. Of course he is also a third cousin-but the closest relationship is great uncle if his sister is my grandmother. His father, Stewart-588 is my 17th great grandfather. Uncle is closer than cousin
The relationship not changing is the part that threw me. It does change-from cousin to uncle. Also the word closeness. Fewest steps is not always closest relationship

Related questions

+3 votes
1 answer
72 views asked Dec 15, 2020 in WikiTree Tech by Dale Roddick G2G Crew (350 points)
+2 votes
4 answers
203 views asked Mar 27, 2020 in WikiTree Tech by Lynn Marois G2G4 (4.4k points)
+7 votes
8 answers
+7 votes
2 answers
+17 votes
2 answers
+8 votes
1 answer
62 views asked Jul 27, 2014 in Genealogy Help by Anonymous Roach G2G6 Pilot (185k points)

WikiTree  ~  About  ~  Help Help  ~  Search Person Search  ~  Surname:

disclaimer - terms - copyright

...