Which father is the "correct" and which two are duplicates? [closed]

+3 votes
120 views

On 23 Aug 2020 Janne (Shoults) Gorman wrote on Vinsant-28:

[[Vansant-107]] and Vinsant-28 appear to represent the same person because: Using the same Will as source

https://www.wikitree.com/index.php?title=Special:MergePerson&user1_name=Van%20Zandt-72&user2_name=VanZandt-29&action=compare

Rachel Van Zandt/Vansant/Vinsant required merging, however the profiles of her duplicate fathers require merging first.  Potential fathers are Vinsant-28, Vansant-107 (project protected) and Van_Zandt-63.  Should the merge be completed into the lowest internal entry number or the "correct" spelling of the surname (if known)?  

WikiTree profile: Garrett Vinsant
closed with the note: Match was rejected
in Genealogy Help by Janne Gorman G2G6 Mach 3 (31.4k points)
closed by Janne Gorman

Bill Vincent changed the father for the duplicate Rachel and wrote this message on the profile for Vansant-107:

There is no real evidence that either this man (Vansant-107) or (
Vansant-14), born about the same time in Pennsylvania, ever lived in North Carolina. It seems to me that there was one man by that name born in Pennsylvania to Rebecca (van der Grist) VanZant (either Van_der_Grist-3 or Van_der_Grist-5, for whom there are duplicate profiles, connected to different parents), and both married to men with the same surnames. That Garrett VanZandt married Anne Groome in Philadelphia in 1738, took the Oath of Allegiance in 1778 in Bucks County, PA, and is reported to have died there after July 1779. Ergo, I don't believe that information and sources related to North Carolina should be included in this profile. Since this man was born, lived, and died in Pennsylvania, any children known to have been born in North Carolina should be moved to Vinsant-28.

It looks like the main issue here is confusion/conflict between three profiles for men named Garret Vansant (or similar):

As Janne says, it looks like there are two different men here. There are also two different women named Rebecca van der Grist identified as the mother of the man born in Pennsylvania, and it looks like https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Vansant-107 might a conflation of two or more men.

Could the members interested in these people undertake an effort to clearly identify (via details of the information and inline citations) the facts in each affected profile that are supported by solid sources (church records, wills, Rev. War service records, etc.) versus the "facts" that come only from online family trees, unsourced findagrave memorials, and other unreliable sources? Pinning down the verifiable facts should help in sorting out these conflicted families.

1 Answer

+6 votes
You should attempt to merge to the correct spelling. It will ask you why when you select a spelling that is a more recent profile. Go ahead and answer that and continue with the merge. Assuming the other profiles have managers, you will need to wait the shorter of getting their approval or 30 days to complete the merge. But still please proceed to propose this and start the process.
by Gurney Thompson G2G6 Pilot (198k points)

Related questions

+7 votes
1 answer
101 views asked Jul 9, 2016 in Genealogy Help by Darlene Athey-Hill G2G6 Pilot (435k points)
+1 vote
1 answer
+3 votes
2 answers
+8 votes
0 answers
+2 votes
1 answer
376 views asked Nov 8, 2013 in Genealogy Help by Brian Howell G2G Rookie (200 points)

WikiTree  ~  About  ~  Help Help  ~  Search Person Search  ~  Surname:

disclaimer - terms - copyright

...