Thank you, Cousin Brian. So I apparently have two paths but the second one is to his sister Prudence. But Prudence did not travel on the Mayflower and she is not a "descendant" of Elder Brewster. Apparently FamilySearch FamilySearch.org/Mayflower doesn't recognize my correct path. Hmmm.
You actually descend from both...
You descend through different lines until the 1800s. Then it seems your separate lines joined into one. So yes, your GSMD membership is correct, and so is WikiTree.
Hope this helps,
Thank you for clarifying. Apparently, the new FamilySearch database FamilySearch.org/Mayflower does not recognize my correct path to Elder William Brewster. They must have looked at the path to his sister (who obviously is not his descendant) and decided I am not a descendant. Hmmm.