Hi Susan -
Sarah Carr is the name listed as being the dau of Carmel Gibson and Mary C (Mullonee) Gibson, but I find no other info on this Carr name until she married. They had another dau Sarah Gibson one year earlier, which is odd in itself (either the pregnancy was timed just right or there's a typo in there somewhere). One explanation is that her father Carmel was married before? I thought also that the two Sarahs, through some fog of ancestry, are the same person. Sarah Carr is listed as marrying Robt A Frasier in CA in 1860. I haven't found anything on dau Sarah Gibson. Brings me back to my Q. Does anyone have any verifiable info on Sarah Carr or Sarah Gibson?