Who were Lydia Hutchinson's parents?

Question

Her marriage record says "of Montgomery" (image of the record is on her profile page). Parents were likely either Israel Hutchinson and Molly Keigwin or Elisha Hutchinson, Jr. and Asenath Loomis. Israel and Molly had a daughter named Lydia who was born in 1801 and died in 1803. Elisha and Israel are the two Hutchinsons in the Montgomery census for 1800. Both were married prior to Lydia's birth and were alive in 1807 (1807 birth comes from her grave). 

She and Emilius were married on 15 Apr 1833 at the same time as Elizabeth Hutchinson and Russell Searle. It is possible that Elizabeth was Lydia's sister.

Can we knock this brick wall down? Thank you for giving it some thought!

 

Comments

Massachusetts, Town and Vital Records, 1620-1988 about Lydia Hutchinson

Name:	Lydia Hutchinson
Event Type:	Marriage
Marriage Place:	Montgomery, Massachusetts
Spouse Name:	Emilius Clapp

 

---

Massachusetts, Marriages, 1633-1850 about Lydia Hutchinson

Name:	Lydia Hutchinson
Gender:	Female
Spouse:	Emilus Clapp
Marriage Date:	31 Mar 1833
City:	Montgomery
County:	Hampden
Source:	Family History Library, Salt Lake City, UT, Film # 0599193.

 

---

Thanks Betty. 

Update: Here are more sources and information that I have found. Between Israel and his brother Elisha, I am now thinking Isreal and Molly were the parents. Still looking for further proofs. 

Israel Hutchinson's wife was Molly Keigwin - daughter of John Keigwin and Lydia Hutchinson. Israel and Molly had a daughter in 1801 that they named Lydia who died in 1803. 

Line possibly goes:

1 John Kiegwin - Lydia Hutchinson

2 Molly Kiegwin - Israel Hutchinson

3 Lydia Hutchinson - Emilius Clapp

Additional data:

MA Vital Records to 1850 - Montgomery Marriages - page 45 - NEHGS

Elisha Jr and Asenath Loomis intention to marry Nov 15 1801 (Montgomery Marriages)

Elizabeth and Russell Searl intention to marry 31 Mar 1833 (Montgomery Marriages)

Lydia and Emilius Clapp intention to marry 31 Mar 1833 (Montgomery Marriages)

Israel and Molly Keigwin intention to marry 22 Oct 1797 (Montgomery Marriages)

 

---

(cont'd)

Notes on Israel and Elisha's father, Elisha

Deacon Elisha died 7 Nov 1819 age 73 (Mont Deaths)

 

Notes on Israel and Elisha's mother, Mercy

 

Mercy (widow Deacon Elisha Hutchinson) died 12 Mar 1836 age 85 (Mont Deaths)

 

Notes on Elisha Hutchinson, Jr

 

Elisha Jr and Asenath Loomis intention to marry Nov 15 1801 (Montgomery

Marriages)

 

Elisha (son Deacon Elisha and Mercy) died Feb 8 1840, age 60y 7m (Mont Deaths)

 

daughter Anna born 17 Jul 1803

 

daughter Asenath born 18 Jun 1813

 

daughter Phidela born 19 May 1805

 

daughter Phidela born 3 Apr 1810

 

Phidela d Elisha Jr. and Assenath, 23 Jul 1809 (Mont Deaths)

 

 

---

Notes on Israel Hutchinson

Israel and Molly Keigwin intention to marry 22 Oct 1797 (Montgomery Marriages)

Molly and Israel marriage record says “Molly Keigwin of Middlefield” and Israel Hutchinson int 22 Oct 1797

Israel (son Elisha and Marcy) died 21 Jan 1813 (Montgomery Deaths)

son Burton (israel and polly) born 16 Dec 1812 (Montgomery Births)

son Israel (isreal and mary) born 30 Aug 1799

daughter Lydia born 12 Feb 1801 (Montgomery births)

daughter Lydia (daughter Israel and Mary), died 3 Oct 1803 (Montgomery Deaths)

Notes on Molly Keigwin

Molly the daughter of John and Lydia Keigwin (Kagwin) (Montgomery births, p 22)

Molly Keigwin, d John and Lydia, b 14 Aug 1778

Israel and Molly Keigwin intention to marry 22 Oct 1797 (Montgomery Marriages)

Molly and Israel marriage record says “Molly Keigwin of Middlefield” and Israel Hutchinson int 22 Oct 1797

Notes on John Keigwin, Jr.

John Keigwin, son of John and Deborah, born 28 Jul 1742 Barbour V 1 page 13

John married Lydia Hutchinson, 27 Oct 1768 Barbour V 1 page 113

Notes on Lt. John Keigwin, Sr.

John married Deborah Parke 15 Aug 1728, died 8 Jul 1775 Barbour V 1 page 13

Lt. John Keigwin died 8 Jul 1775 Barbour Vol 1 page 13

Notes on Lydia Hutchinson

Lydia Hutchinson married John Keigwin 27 Oct 1768 (Barbour V1 page 113)

Lydia Huchinson daughter of Israel and Mary (born 28 May 1744) -(Barbour 29 May 1744)