1) Caroline Held, PA County Marriages, 1885-1950
Marriage to George Applegate 1 Jun 1861, Philadelphia, PA Groom is 22 est. birth 1839, bride is 20, est. birth 1841
2) There is also a marriage of Caroline Wahl born 1841 to George Applegate 12 Jun 1861
3) The 1880 US Census, Philadelphia, PA has Carolina Applegate age 39 and George Applegate 40, both born PA. Son-in-Law George Wahl age 31 and daughter Kate Wahl age 28.