Are there 2 Catherine Wartmans?

Question

There seems to be a major confusion between Catherine Wartman Caverly Wartman-21 and Catherine Wartman Snook Wartman-63.  They appear to have the same parents.  They are born about the same time in Kingston, Ontario.  They marry their respective partners within months of each other.   I could really use some help sorting this out.  I have not identified any definitive sources to separate the 2.

Answer 1

The Relationship finder has the same birth year and death year for each one.

Comments

but she can't be married to 2 different men just months apart.