On 1 Nov 2020 William Smith wrote on Hollenbeck-472: This couple were my 4th great grandparents via their daughter Clara who married William Smith. Their son John Hollenbeck married William's sister Mariam Smith and their daughter Lovina Hollenbeck married Baltus Smith sibling of William and Mariam. As Gloria Jackson indicated in her little bio, there were only three Hollenbeck sons being Jacob, John and David. Nowhere to be found was there a son Andrew. In 1808, Nathaniel and Hannah were living in Hamilton Twp, Northumberland, Ontario where they had lived since approximately 1797. There were at least two other Nathaniel Hollenbecks in Ontario in the same general time period. Perhaps this is the reason that posters show them having children born in Vermont, Quebec and Buffalo, New York all while they were living in Hamilton Township, Ontario. Also to my chagrin, Nathaniel has been anointed with a middle name, Leslie.
