This question is more complicated than you might realize. You must decide which standard you are going to use: e.g., APA, MLA or Turabian. Check them out to see proper citation style you want to use.
MLA citation would be:
Hinshaw, William Wade. Encyclopedia of American Quaker Genealogy. vol. 1, Edwards Brothers Inc., 1936, p. 1021.
I would leave out the reference to p. 36. That is a reference to the original document but you don't have the title of the original documents so it is irrelevant. YOUR source is Hinshaw not the original document.
You asked about proper citation not the best citation. However, the best citation would be to the original records. I've check out the records on ancestry.com but can't find the records on births you want to cite.