Katherine, thank-you for taking the time to do this look-up. The Forsters of Scotland are not as simple to research as the English branch. So in this case ... you did good!
I saw that one of your sources was already on the profile, and you offered two indexes from a relatively easy identifiable repository that had vital dates in the ballpark of what the profile stated. And because no other sources were given, the 2 dates from the indexes offer a little more support.
Ordinarily ... for massively-in-common ancestors, avoid the indexes and go for primary or a good secondary source (inq. pm., wills, parish reg. baptism, etc). But when no other date is found or cited on the profile, note your findings (try to put it under a Notes or Research Notes header).