I felt that way too, but after purchasing the book and reading it through I think it's a useful structure on which to hang citations. Takes a minute to get used to, but ensures that others will find their way to what you did, in almost any situation.
Are all my citations that good? No, definitely not, I am mostly copy/pasting from the provided citations on places like familysearch and findAGrave, or using the Ancestry Citer app. But as I'm eating this elephant (i.e. my families' profiles) one of the steps I will take someday will be to revisit and revise to match Evidence Explained format as much as possible.