Here is Daniel Bly's research on Melchior Brombach (b. 1664, son of Jost Brombach), which Bly posted (with footnotes and quotations in the original German) on the profile of Melchior Brumbach-28 at https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Brumbach-28
Melchior Brumbach son of Jost Brombach and Catherina Klein, was born at Muesen and baptized 15 May 1664. [1] Melchior was thirteen years old when he was confirmed at Müsen, Christmas, 1677 and first sponsored a baptism at Müsen in September, 1695, when he sponsored Johann Melchior, son of Johann Georg and Anna Barbara Brumbach. In that record he was identified as "Melchior Brombach aus Müsen noch Jungergesell "(still a bachelor). In the following years he may have left Müsen to work in nearby villages but was close enough to come back in 1704 to sponsor Johann Melchior, son of Johannes and Margaretha and a second son of Johann Georg and Anna Barbara in 1705. He was called "gewesen Melchior Brombach aus Müsen, noch ledige Gesell" (still single fellow formerly from Müsen), when he sponsored a child of Friedrich Höfer (brother-in-law) at Müsen in March of 1707. [2] He was listed as "Melchior Brombach von Müessen," when he show up at nearby Ernsdorf and sponsored Johann Melchior Kaltschmidt, son of his sister, Anna Catherina, and her husband, Friedrich Kaltschmidt, July 24, 1713. [3]
Here is a transcript of the complete records regarding Melchior Brombach:
Records of Melchior Brombach / Brumbach at Müsen, Nassau-Siegen. Birth: Anno 1664, den 15 Tag May ist Melchior, Jost Brombach und Catherina Eheleuth eheliche Sohn getauft, Pate: Melchior Eckhardt. Kirchenbuch Evangelisch-Reformierte Müsen, Volume I, Taufen, 1649-1764, p 11a,
Confirmation: Nativitat 1677. Melchior Brombach, Jost Brombach Sohn von Müssen. (One of seven comfirmed at that time. Kirchenbuch Evangelisch-Reformierte Müsen, Volume I, Konfirmation, 1660-1672, p. 153.
Sponsor of Baptisms: 1695-Dom 16 post Trinit. Johann Georg Brumbach, Anna Barbara, ehel, einen junge Sohn Tauffen lassen. Gev. Melchior Brumbach, noch jungergesell aus Müsen Das Kind gennant Melchior, natus, 2 Sept. Kirchenbuch Evangelisch-Reformierte Müsen, Volume I, Taufen, 1649-1764, p. 39.
1704 20 Aprill Haben Johannes Brumbach, Anna Margaretha eheleuth einen junge Sohn taufft lassen. Gevtt, is gewesen Melchior Brumbach aus Müssen. Dess Kind is gennant worden Johann Melchior. Kirchenbuch Evangelisch-Reformierte Müsen, Volume I, Taufen, 1649-1764, p. 50.
1705 Auff Pfingstmontag haben Georg Brombach, Anna Barbara eheleuth einen Sohn tauff lassen. Gevtt is gewesen Melchior Brombach dess Kind is gennant worden Johann Melchior. Kirchenbuch Evangelisch-Reformierte Müsen, Volume I, Taufen, 1649-1764, p. 51.
1707 13 Martii hat Friedrich Höfer, Anna Magdalena eheleute einen Junge Sohn tauffen lassen, Gevatter is gewesen Melchior Brumbach aus Muessen noch lediger gesell. Das Kind is gennant worden Johann Melchior. Kirchenbuch Evangelisch-Reformierte Müsen, Volume I, Taufen, 1649-1764, p. 52a.
1713 Ernsdorf, July 18th Friedrich Kaldschmidt Kirchen Elster hiesig Gemeinde, Anna Catherina Eheleuthe einen Sohn. Gevatter war Melchior Brombach von Muessen. Dess Kind Johann Melchior, getaufft 24th ej. Kirchenbuch Evangelisch-Reformierte Ferndorf, Taufen, Volume 3, 1677-1716, p. 333.
No further records for an adult Melchior Brombach / Brumbach can be found in the existing Müsen church books until Johann Melchior, son of Johannes and Margaretha came of age (confirmed 1720, married 1737).
The July 1713 baptism at Ernsdorf is the last reference to Melchior in any church records. A reasonable argument can be made that he is the Melchior Brombach, who left in 1713 with a group of others from the area, went to Virginia and established the Germanna Colony in 1714.
In my next post (perhaps tomorrow), if this discussion doesn't go off on a tangent, I will present Holtzclaw's evidence and what he infers from it.