John Gunning was at Bunker Hill, then evacuated as a UEL - passenger list discrepancies

Question

On 8 Nov 2021 Shirlea Smith wrote on Gunning-231:

Anyone know anything about this? There are several versions of the Amphitrite's passenger list. The Gunnings seem to be the only family whose child sometimes appears and sometimes doesn't appear. 

The first two transcriptions don't include a child

From the  official Loyalist website: no child

From PANB: no child

From a GenWeb project:   https://sites.rootsweb.com/~nsannapo/nypass.html

This one does include a child

What was going on here? 

Any way to see the original of these transcriptions?

And what happened to the lady, who was definitely not his wife (she was home in England with their daughter) and the child?

All theories and all research welcome!

Answer 1

Stephen Davidson is a regular contributor to the weekly LOYALIST TRAILS. You could contact him, as the PANB cites him as the transcriber.

Comments

Thank you!