I did change it to green, but it didn't stick. When I went back to the profile to see if the photo was there, it wasn't. When I went back to the image page, it was red again. I found the image page by using the changes tab, and saw the thumbnail.
I was wondering if these problems didn't start with the former problem of having all of those extra people on my watchlist. That seemed to happen when I asked my cousin, who is PM for a profile, to be on the trusted list for that profile to add a photo - and he ok'd it, and I got his watchlist mixed with mine. Weird.