I'm angry and I need help

+21 votes
572 views

I'm working on the US Black Heritage Challenge, adding military stickers to profiles that need them. In the course of my work, I came across Cleophus Walter Valentine.

For those of you who may not know, Cleophus was one of the Tuskegee Airmen. But Cleophus didn't end his service after serving as an Airman. He re-enlisted in 1947 and served in the Korean War and Vietnam. He retired from the service as a Major in the United States Air Force.

What makes me angry about this?

  1. No Wikipedia article
  2. No obituary
  3. Very little documentation in fold3
  4. No newspaper.com mentions
  5. Only one mention in genealogybank.com
  6. No obituary in ObitsArchive.com
  7. No marriage records for his marriage

This man was a Tuskegee Airman who served his country honorably for two decades. He deserves more recognition than this. This is Veterans Day. Can we give this man his due?

WikiTree profile: Cleophus Valentine
in Genealogy Help by Paul Schmehl G2G6 Pilot (148k points)
edited by Paul Schmehl

Cleophus is named in two Congressional records regarding Tuskegees/Veterans from Michigan prior to their receipt of the collective Congressional Medal they received in 2006. The links are here from 2003 (p.7) and 2004:

Sadly, Cleophus passed before this award was given. His profile is a wonderful tribute to him.

Thank you, Denise. I'll add both to his profile.

5 Answers

+31 votes
 
Best answer
Hi Paul - part of what we do here on WikiTree with the USBH project is to bring more recognition and awareness to people like Cleophus, so you're helping to give him his due by working on his profile and his family. I think part of the lack of documentation might just be the time period and/or location(s) he lived in - different locations have different privacy laws, so not all more "recent" records are available online. Sometimes it's actually harder to find records for people who were born in the last 100 years. And as honorable and important as his military service was, those serving don't always get a lot of recognition in newspapers/Wikipedia unless they are killed in action or do something particularly heroic. But here on WikiTree, we can honor each and everyone of them and you're helping to do that.
by Christy Melick G2G6 Pilot (106k points)
selected by Valorie Zimmerman
Great response, Christy. And this weekend's sprint is all about honoring them!
+23 votes
We all get frustrated about the lack of records. Perhaps you could call or write to a library in the town where he died and see if someone can find an obituary for you. Maybe if you find his obituary, you could make him a Wikipedia article. Very few of the Tuskegee Airmen actually have their own articles.

In my opinion, the best thing to do to honor Cleophus would be to work on getting his family connected. He had lots of aunts and uncles who don't have profiles. (His father didn't even have the African-American sticker until I put it on just now!)
by Kate Schmidt G2G6 Pilot (121k points)
I agree whole-heartedly with Kate.  I'm working on his mother's tree right now.  She also did not have the African-American sticker and only had a stub profile.
I found his wife, but I can't find her maiden name, so I can't add her to the tree. Hopefully someone can unearth that. Her FamilySearch ID is GN15-WMJ.

I've found two records - Find a Grave and Veterans Gravesites.
Paul, this is pretty par for the course in research African-American genealogy. It's not easy but I look at is as a challenge. I'm still looking for information on a big NFL star, Emlen Tunnell, and getting good information on his father is TOUGH. I have added lots of Tunnells, but can't pinpoint his father's family! I just keep looking for more.

Sometimes there is no obituary because obits have to be paid for. Sometimes there is a simple death notice and that's it, and sometimes there's not even that. We just keep looking for whatever clues we can pick up in our research.

I know it's frustrating. I'm sure that everyone in the USBH project has run up against similar roadblocks. We just hope to move the roadblocks down the road a little bit more.
+15 votes
Thanks for bringing attention to his profile and general lack of information. I was able to find a link to an obituary for his second wife on Legacy.com, but it is just a very basic obituary with only the information about her Celebration of Life. Unfortunately, obituaries can be expensive and sometimes the funeral home does not do a proper obituary even when requested by the family. My daughter-in-law provided all the necessary information for her mother's obituary and the only thing that got published was her name and date of death. Very heartbreaking and frustrating for my daughter-in-law.

I have added the burial information and FindAGrave memorial for his second wife and will continue to assist in researching him and his family.
by Emily Holmberg G2G6 Pilot (155k points)
+11 votes
Paul, love your passion!  I know for me personally, and I have observed, that passion fuels a lot of what gets done on WikiTree!
by Bartley McRorie G2G6 Pilot (164k points)
+10 votes

Paul, the work you're doing is very important, as well as incredibly time consuming and emotionally draining.  I am all too well aware of the lack of records documenting the major life events of African Americans.

The last thing I would do is to belittle your motivation and efforts or the amazing contributions of Cleophus to our country, but I don't think this situation is unique to African Americans who served in the military.

Cleophus has a lot in common with my husband, a White American who spent 26 years in the Air Force before retiring as a Lieutenant Colonel, flew 196 combat missions in Vietnam (that's the officially credited number - his logbook documents over 400, but many were classified or couldn't be claimed for other reasons), and ended up with about 30 medals, including the silver star awarded for his actions as a wild weasel pilot the first night of the fire bombing of Hanoi.

He died a year and a half ago and his children and I are still waiting for his funeral to be scheduled.  I expect he will have an obituary after that occurs - if it ever does.  First I was told there would be a 1 to 1.5 year wait and would be contacted in 9 months to schedule it.  They contacted me in 11 months, but only to say there would be a 6-9 month wait for them to contact me to schedule it in about a year and they offered to expedite it if I am willing to forego the military honors he is entitled to.  I was so insulted by this that I wrote to my congressional representative and both senators asking them to persuade the military to treat deceased veterans better.  Two of them sent an automated response, indicating that they received my message and would address it soon.  The third didn't even do that, but all three added me to their mailing list, regularly telling me all about how hard they're working on my behalf and inviting me to contribute to their campaigns.

Since there has been no obituary, I wouldn't expect there to be any newspaper.com, genealogybank.com, or obitsarchive.com records for him and you won't find any of his three marriage records anywhere either.  Like Cleophus, he also does not have a Wikipedia article.

EDITED TO ADD:  Unlike Cleophus, whose profile fully honors his life, thanks to Paul's efforts, my husband's profile is very incomplete.  Working on it is still too traumatic for me, so it just has to wait until I am able to do it justice.  Also unlike Cleophus, as a close relative I know all about his life, so it won't be at all daunting to locate information to include.

by Gaile Connolly G2G Astronaut (1.2m points)
edited by Gaile Connolly
Grrrrrrrrrr....

Related questions

+3 votes
1 answer
+1 vote
1 answer
+13 votes
5 answers

WikiTree  ~  About  ~  Help Help  ~  Search Person Search  ~  Surname:

disclaimer - terms - copyright

...