G2G: Is the following book considered a reliable source?

+10 votes
625 views

Is the following book considered a reliable source.  I have been using it for some time now and never thought about asking.  The are citation throughout the book for various individuals on the genealogy of the book, so I assumed it was reliable.  All data I have found in the book thus far has corresponded with other source I have found.

"Contributions to the History of the Kip Family of New York and New Jersey" by Edward Purple, privately printed in 1877.

Most Edward Purple books are considered reliable, so again, I assumed this is considered good.

in Genealogy Help by Arthur Van Riper G2G6 Mach 2 (25.3k points)
recategorized by Arthur Van Riper

Arthur, to what extent does the book cite its sources for the information included?

There are reference citations and footnotes on the majority of the pages.  The three references I have checked seem legitimate...


4 Answers

+11 votes
If this book is a quick way to add information, children, marriages, births, deaths, etc, it maybe fine to start with, but the importance of primary and good secondary sources cannot be understated.  Most books I use as a stepping stone to locating the actual records.  So I will go into a book find a person I'm looking for, and check out what sources are in the book for the person.  Then I will hunt down those sources. If the sources just lead to "other books" and not to actual records I'm less likely to be inclined to believe them.  It is very easy to just cite another persons works, over and over to complete a book.  This doesn't verify anything about the ones in the books, unless the sources /citations/references lead back to original documents/ land records, gov. agency records @ the time of the event involving the person ie; birth, death, marrg, bapt, census, Licenses, notary, wills, etc.  

If a book tells you where a person was from, search that area, checking Vital records, use Family Search- "records"  to start (its free), searching records, (not personal trees).  put in the persons' name, and location, and a time frame, if you have spouse or parents names add them too, this will cut down the clutter, while searching and will bring you to possible primary source record images.  In this way you will see if the infos in the book are viable and reliable, but you will also have the links at family search that verify the infos from the book are correct.

hope this helps, sorry I'm long-winded sometimes

Arora
by Arora Anonymous G2G6 Pilot (178k points)

Your answer is indeed very helpful; thank you! I'm quite new to all this, so I'm trying to figure out how to work with such info. And you provided me with some useful pieces of info; thanks a lot! There are so many sources online nowadays, and sometimes it's hard to understand whether it's a good one to use or not. And I'm also a student so I need a lot of sources. Sometimes when I have difficulties with finding one or just can do it, I use the help of https://edubirdie.com/write-my-essay-for-me and just don't have to worry anymore. Writing and analyzing are still hard for me, so trusting professionals is the best option. But I'm becoming better and better so that soon I will be able to do everything myself.


smiley you're welcome Clare.  happy hunting!


Thank you Arora.  Happy Hunting.

+5 votes
You will get various answers, but the short answer is yes.
by Jimmy Honey G2G6 Pilot (221k points)

Thank you Jimmy.  Happy Hunting.

+4 votes
There are reference citations and footnotes on the majority of the pages.  The three references I have checked seem legitimate...
by Arthur Van Riper G2G6 Mach 2 (25.3k points)

+6 votes
It is important to not only check to see if the sources are references to actual documents, but to also read those documents to see if they provide the information to prove the information given. There was a book published that included my family that also listed sources to actual records.  However, when reading ALL THE INFORMATION in the actual record I discovered the author had only cited part of the record and what was in the record that was not mentioned totally disproved the information given in the book.  Also, court records not mentioned in the book proved that a man listed as being the oldest son was in fact not a son.  It is important to check and thoroughly read the existing records and any records that may have been discovered since the book was published.
by Carol Wilder G2G6 Mach 7 (78.7k points)

Thank you Carol.  Happy Hunting.

Related questions

+5 votes
0 answers
+4 votes
1 answer
+4 votes
1 answer
asked Sep 18, 2020 in Genealogy Help by Anne Burnham G2G6 (9.8k points)
+3 votes
2 answers
+4 votes
2 answers
+6 votes
2 answers
+4 votes
2 answers
asked May 12, 2024 in Genealogy Help by Mary Boyer G2G6 (9.1k points)
...