not trying to reply using personal email because my one of my big faults is being long winded - thought with your points you might be inundated, thanks chris youre right about the confusing at first bit. I think I have done that I have at least done the first part and I found what I believe are bits of the two cousins, eg I know the 1/10/1858 is my peters dob but I have seen his grave in murchison and he died long before 1033 whereas the link still has the guy who took out citizenship (no dob on his certificate) in daylesford in 1906 with the dob of my peter who was naturalized in preston. so I think part of the original info was imported from a professional site and I have found some odd info in trial look ups there before so I dont think the administrators are to blame and I hope we can all help each other in sorting which details belong to which pietro - I have emailed them, I am over cautious with stating something as fact or not cross checking everything I find before it goes on the books because of hundreds of hours chasing back a paternal great gf in scotland only to discover it was a close relative born and living around the corner from my relo. same name close dob son of same name as my gf but he never left scotland so it was back to the drawing board. A cousin collected the paternal family tree whollus cabollus from someone she met on the internet and she sent it to me believing it to be correct but as I traced it back I found the same mistake so someone else had the same problem. Ultimately it is a simple math problem a cant be the son/daughter of b because b is dead when a is born. I told her but she was blinkered by the fact tht she had worked hard and got very little and suddenly she had the tree back to 1200 or 1400 ad handed to her so she went ahead and published her page - I cant blame her - I just dont think of it as my family tree.
This site is great though and I think finding the first composite page has meant I can help another user because I think cousin pietro and sarah are the parents of her lafranchi she has no info on. the composite page doesn't come up when you spell the name as we do so if she doesn't realise this she will not know it exists - she can make up her own mind about 1 or 2 pietros and if the latter which one is hers.