PGM Mary (Hull) Pinney born 1618 has PP child born 1615??

Question

http://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Hull-482

I am working through the Hull Families who emigrated prior to 1640. Speciffically right now I am on Mary Hull who was born in 1618 in Crewkerne, Somerset, England and who married Humphrey Pinney in Dorchester, NEW England by 1636. 

I see listed as their child, Abigail (Pinney) Anonymous, which is project protected and PGM. http://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Pinney-34

This Abigail was born in 1615 in Dorchester, Dorset, England.  How can she be the child of Humphrey Pinney and his wife Mary (Hull) Pinney?

Am I missing something here?  This doesn't seem to be correct.

Cheryl Skordahl (Aldrich-908)

 

 

 

Answer 1

Anderson (v3, p 1480) says Abigail, daughter of Humphrey Pinney and Mary Hull, was born in Windsor on November 26, 1654,

Based on Anderson, it looks like a lot of other info in Abigail's profile may be wrong as well - eg children and DOD.

Answer 2

The wife of Deacon John Moore is unknown.  It has been guessed in the past that she was Abigail Pinney which is apparently where this profile comes from.  In fact, neither her first name nor last name is known.

The two children attached to her are also just junk of no relevance whats so ever.  They have no spouses and no children themselves.  All three profiles are probably just left over junk as people tried to correct errors.

At a minimum, Abigail Anonymous formerly Pinney-34 and her children Hannah Moore-18057 and James Moore-18056 should be disconnected.  Ideally, these profiles would be merged away as they serve no purpose.

Answer 3

I looks like Abigail Pinney's profile is a mix to 2 people: the daughter of Humphrey Pinney and the wife of John Moore. Since according to John Moore's profile, Anderson says his wife is unknown, I suggest moving the children to John Moore, stripping out the DOD info, and merging the profile with the other profile for Abigail Pinney.