My brother and I (Toemmes-1 and Toemmes-4) match Weathford-199 on chromo 12 at 14+ cM. Additionally I match her on 3 and 8 at 9.8 and 8.3 cMs respectively, So I consider ti a fairly good match.
FTDNA predicts we at 5+ cousins. GEDmatch predicts we are 4.5+/- MRCA/Gend so I consider them consistent.
However, "paper" connection show 7-1 cousin (FTM) and 8 cousin (WikiTree) connection and while not a maternal or X connection this is along a great part of my suspect maternal line.
So, to me, it seems that there has to be a closer connection as yet undiscovered.
What say you?