It's time for December Roll of Honor Military Showcase nominations!

+17 votes
355 views

It's time for nominations for our Roll of Honor Military Showcase profile. This month's theme is prisoners of war. Be sure to add your nominations to the space page and good luck!!

https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Space:Military_Showcase_Profiles

in The Tree House by Paula J G2G6 Pilot (280k points)
Please do nominate your profiles! Not only do we get to showcase them during voting but they serve as excellent examples to new members on how to create profiles to honor their ancestors.
Pvt. Samuel Batton, (Batton-104) (1835 - 1875) 77th Ohio Volunteer Infantry, was a POW at Camp Ford, Tyler, Texas for about ten months. He was Captured at the Battle of Mark's Mills, Arkansas. More details in his profile. He was one of my great grandfather's four older brothers who served in the Civil War. One brother, Jacob Battin, was KIA at the Battle of Pittsburgh Landing (Shiloh). Another brother, John Battin, died of Measles at Nashville, TN in 1865. Another brother, Pvt. William H Battin, 25th Ohio Volunteer Infantry, survived the war, but was killed in an ambush by several of Chief Crazy Horse's braves on the Tongue River, Montana on January 3, 1877.

5 Answers

+6 votes
I posted one, though I feel it's a bit unfinished. I'm waiting for permission to use a WWII photo for Russell.(been waiting for months, and I don't want to hound the guy!)
by Natalie Trott G2G Astronaut (1.3m points)
edited by Natalie Trott
That is an excellent profile! Thank you!!
Thanks!
You can continue working on it but it looks wonderful right now!
+8 votes

I have at least one that deserves honor Private Abel William Baker.

by David Wilson G2G6 Pilot (122k points)
David, nice work!
Thank-you!
I remember him. That is an excellent profile!
+7 votes

John Crockett Hudson, my favorite ancestor!!! Here's a tidbit published about him during his time at Camp Morton:

 

Why the Rebels Wore Ragged Clothes

Published in the Confederate Veteran, written by Elder J.K. Womack. [17]

The legislators of Indiana and Governor Morton, with their wives and daughters, went on a visit of inspection to the prisoners in Camp Morton in 1864. The Confederates were called out for dress parade and were made to look as well as possible. This distinguished body rode in fine carriages. One lady had her carriage stopped about ten feet from the line. Opening the side door of the carriage and pushing her head out, she asked:"Why do you Rebel soldiers dress so poorly?" Crockett Hudson, of Eagleville, Tenn., replied: "Gentlemen of the South have two suits-one that they wear among nice people and one that they wear when killing hogs, and that is the one in which we are dressed to-day." She ordered the carriage to move on.

by Summer Orman G2G6 Mach 9 (94.7k points)
Summer I added him to our list of December POW profiles
Excellent job!
Thanks!
I had ancestors at Camp Morton as well. That is an excellent description if their spirit!
+5 votes

I added my 3rd-great-grandfather's brother John G. Gatlin, who was a prisoner of war at Rock Island Barracks during the Civil War.

https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Gatlin-228

by E. Gatlin G2G6 Mach 1 (16.1k points)
Elisabeth...

you could remove the [[Category: American Civil War, POW]], that is used as a higher level container and you have the more specific [[Category: Confederate American Civil War POWs]], and actually that could be removed since you have the actual camp he was held in [[Category: Rock Island Prison, Rock Island, Illinois]]

but, since the camp category name does not contain the conflict, or a POW indicator, you should keep that one in so people do not make the snap judgement that he was a criminal in a prison if they do not follow the links/read the rest of the profile to see it in context.

i think it is great that you were able to find/includ the muster rolls/loyalty oath images
Thank you! I removed [[Category: American Civil War, POW]].
+5 votes
Added Rifleman Ralph Orville Huntington of the 1st Battalion of The Royal Rifles of Canada. https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Huntington-1074

I knew very little about the Canadian participation in the defense of Hong Kong from the Japanese before now.

It's sad he died a POW at just age 19.
by Melissa McKay G2G6 Mach 3 (38.2k points)
edited by Melissa McKay
Melissa,

you have him in a category for KIA, that should be changed to [[Category: Died in Military Service]]   (if you use template {{Died in Military Service}} it will show an image in the profile as well as add it to the category)

right now it is just a global category, but as we move forward with category standardization, we will be making some new categories to be more specific about the conflict/country/cause of death

same goes to the POW camps used by the Japanese for Allied prisoners, someday we hope to get categories for them created as well

keith
Thanks Keith changes made.
I have been thinking about this category and am not sure that the name suits it.

If say during peace time a solder was run over by a truck and died.  Does DMS apply? They certainly were in military service when they died.

I know the example isn't the best but it is what I think of with DMS.

What about the soldier that had a heart attack on base does DMS apply here?

How about DMC died as a result of a military campaign or DMA died as a result of a military action for the category name?
at the present time, Died in Military covers any death of in service personnel not Killed in Action.

Definition for Killed in Action is death from enemy action, either immediate or from wounds and died before reaching medical treatment at aid station, hospital, etc,

since there are so many possibilities for death, we have been thinking add a couple more to break things down a little more to group service related causes and  generic health, living conditions, etc

Died of Wounds - battle related wounds being the primary cause of death within a short timeframe, days/weeks/maybe months.  if someone died years later it does not fall into this category, even if the claim was death due to being gassed in the war causing other complications, infections from amputation site, etc.

Died while Prisoner - starvation, mistreatment, shot while attempting to escape, disease, etc

Died of Disease - no so prevalent today, but before medical treatments were more effective...  more people died of disease in the American Civil War than were killed in action.

Died in Military Service - then becomes a catch all for both peace and wartime deaths due to vehicle accidents, heart attacks, training incidents, falling in the bathtub, bar fights, suicide, etc.

keith
There is a slippery slope of what the Department of Defense considers in attributing a veteran's death to their military service.  Examples would include the cancers known to be caused by exposure to Agent Orange, Radiation, Asbestos and other environmental hazards so many veterans encountered due to their military service.
we are not the dept of defense or medical examiner trying to assign blame/cause of death

a service person in 1970, exposed to agent orange, discharged in 1972, died of cancer from agent orange in 2016 did not die in military service

a service person home on leave, killed in a car crash, died in military service

Related questions

+5 votes
0 answers
+9 votes
1 answer
171 views asked Jul 17, 2019 in The Tree House by Jo Gill G2G6 Pilot (167k points)

WikiTree  ~  About  ~  Help Help  ~  Search Person Search  ~  Surname:

disclaimer - terms - copyright

...