Thank you so much for the information and yes, this is the same family. Since I still do not have specific information on Mary Ann (Bender) Bobb, I was wondering if you might have any suggestions on how to trace her? I have found some Church records that list her children's baptisms and she has given each child the middle name of their sponsor. (Tillie, Thompson, Valentine, Bender). I am unable to find a marriage certificate for this union. Any tips would be greatly appreciated. Thank you!