Maggie, I've removed the unmerged status on both of the profiles and proposed the merge again. Looking at them, I would agree that by all appearances they are duplicates. Perhaps the two PMs will look at it now (or someone on the trusted list) and merge them. What sometimes happens is that someone on Wikitree that isn't the PM for one of the profiles, sets the match to unmerged, at which point it basically vanishes off the radar and just sits. You can now, should you choose, send a message to each of the profile managers and ask them to approve the merge. If you don't get a response, you can file an unresponsive profile manager note.