I have proof of these children of Wm Eli & Elisabeth Garten.
I knew my great Grandmother, Melcenia well.
Shannon Lee 1863-1939 ( Find a grave # 114576783 married Melceina Miller 24 Dec 1885, She born Nov 19, 1870 died March 10 1959 find a grave (114576247).
Children with wife Mary JANE Johnson (have it hand written by Eli) in family religous book
John R. born 11 June 1844 ,
Julian Ann born 19 April 1846( died 19 dec 1928, Talcott, Summers County.)