Which Elizabeth is the correct first wife of Daniel Stroud?

+8 votes
189 views
Daniel Stroud was married twice, first to Elizabeth who bore him 11 children and secondly to Mary Paul.  I found two profiles on wikitree who claim to be Daniel's wife Elizabeth.

Elizabeth Shoemaker [Shoemaker-859], the daughter of William Showmaker and Susanna

Elizabeth Schoonmaker [Schoonmker-96], the daughter of Frederick Shoonmaker and Elizabeth.

Sometimes, names get changed in translation from one language to another, but the parents of the two Elizabeth's don't match.  Yet the birth and death dates of the two do match.  Does anyone have any verifiable evidence that one of the two Elizabeth's is the correct 1st wife?
WikiTree profile: Daniel Stroud
in Genealogy Help by David Hughey G2G Astronaut (1.6m points)

 All Results

Daniel Stroud

 in the U.S., Sons of the American Revolution Membership Applications, 1889-1970

VIEWU.S., Sons of the American Revolution Membership Applications, 1889-1970

      Name: Daniel Stroud
      Birth Date: 22 May 1772
      Death Date: 2 Mar 1846
      SAR Membership: 46844
      Role: Ancestor
      Application Date: Feb 1928
      Father: Jacob Stroud
      Mother: Elizabeth MacDowell
      Spouse: Elizabeth Shoemaker
      Children: George McDowell Stroud

      Source Citation

      Volume: 235

      Source Information

      Ancestry.com. U.S., Sons of the American Revolution Membership Applications, 1889-1970 [database on-line]. Provo, UT, USA: Ancestry.com Operations, Inc., 2011.

       

       All Results

      Elizabeth Shoemaker

       in the U.S., Quaker Meeting Records, 1681-1935

      VIEWU.S., Quaker Meeting Records, 1681-1935

          Name: Elizabeth Shoemaker
          Birth Date: 15 Jun 1774
          Birth Date on Image: 15 Sixth 1774
          Birth Place: Montgomery, Pennsylvania
          Residence Place: Cheltenham, Philadelphia
          Father: William Shoemaker
          Mother: Susanna Shoemaker
          Event Type: Birth
          Monthly Meeting: Abington Monthly Meeting
          Historical Meeting Data: Search for this monthly meeting in the 'Quaker Monthly Meetings Index'
          Type (Orthodox or Hicksite): Pre-Hicksite
          Yearly Meeting: Philadelphia Yearly Meeting
          Meeting State: Pennsylvania
          Meeting County: Montgomery

          Source Citation

          Swarthmore College; Swarthmore, Pennsylvania; Minutes, 1629-1812; Collection: Quaker Meeting Records; Call Number: RG2/Ph/A2 3.8

          Source Information

          Ancestry.com. U.S., Quaker Meeting Records, 1681-1935 [database on-line]. Provo, UT, USA: Ancestry.com Operations, Inc., 2014.

          Original data:

          • Swarthmore, Quaker Meeting Records. Friends Historical Library, Swarthmore College, Swarthmore, Pennsylvania.
          • North Carolina Yearly Meeting Minutes. Hege Friends Historical Library, Guilford College, Greensboro, North Carolina.
          • Indiana Yearly Meeting Minutes. Earlham College Friends Collection & College Archives, Richmond, Indiana.
          • Haverford, Quaker Meeting Records. Haverford College, Haverford, Pennsylvania.

           

           

          The Schoonmakers were a different church

           All Results

          Elizabeth Schoonmaker

           in the U.S., Dutch Reformed Church Records in Selected States, 1639-1989

          VIEWU.S., Dutch Reformed Church Records in Selected States, 1639-1989

              Name: Elizabeth Schoonmaker
              Event Type: Baptism
              Baptism Date: 1774
              Baptism Place: Stone Ridge, New York, USA
              Church: Marbletown Church
              Father: Frederik Schoonmaker
              Mother: Elizabeth Schoonmaker

              Source Citation

              The Archives of the Reformed Church in America; New Brunswick, New Jersey; Marbletown Church, Church Records, Baptisms, Marriages, Members, 1746-1871

              Source Information

              Ancestry.com. U.S., Dutch Reformed Church Records in Selected States, 1639-1989 [database on-line]. Provo, UT, USA: Ancestry.com Operations, Inc., 2014.

               

              1 Answer

              0 votes
              Our family is a relative to Mary Paul the second wife of Daniel Stroud.  We have Elizabeth Shoemaker as the daughter of William Shoemaker and Susannah Richardson, because they all lived in Pennsylvania.  

              It looks like the Elizabeth Schoonmaker daughter of Frederik was born in New York.  The distance would make it improbable for this person to be the wife of Daniel Stroud.
              by Th Fager G2G1 (1.6k points)

              Related questions

              +4 votes
              1 answer
              +5 votes
              0 answers
              +4 votes
              2 answers
              141 views asked Jan 10, 2020 in Genealogy Help by Karen Lange G2G Crew (670 points)
              +10 votes
              2 answers
              +6 votes
              1 answer
              71 views asked May 22, 2019 in Appreciation by Anonymous Fiser G2G1 (1.4k points)
              +5 votes
              1 answer
              54 views asked May 21, 2019 in Appreciation by Anonymous Stroud G2G4 (4.5k points)
              +1 vote
              1 answer

              WikiTree  ~  About  ~  Help Help  ~  Search Person Search  ~  Surname:

              disclaimer - terms - copyright

              ...