Erroneous Find a Grave DB Error?

Question

When I check my Suggestions, I see two Find A Grave 572 errors, but I don't see what the difference is that's triggering the suggestion. For example, Barbara Burger's name and birth/death dates seem to match what's in FAG. Is there a problem I'm missing, or should I mark the error as false?

Suggestion	Link	Info	Name	Rel.	Birth	Death	Gender		Manager	Marriage
572 FindAGrave - Linked grave not matching profile	Burger-2129  H	88972140	Barbara Kagarise (Burger)		uncertain 1789-07-31 Bedford, Pennsylvania, USA	certain 1848-06-05 Everett, Bedford, Pennsylvania, USA	Female		Cebull-1
	88972140		Barbara Burger Kagarise		1789-07-31 Bedford County, Pennsylvania, USA	1848-06-05 Everett, Bedford County, Pennsylvania, USA

Answer 1

I believe there were some ‘false’ suggestions in the latest report as the details of working with the new FindAGrave site are being flushed out. I’m waiting until next week to address mine.

Comments

Correct FindAGrave completed there cut over to the new site format but the source files that we (Wikitree+) were using to compare hadn't been updated when the 'Suggestions' Report was run last week - so there are/were more 'Suggestions' reported than there actually are.  The recommendation is at this stage just ignore any FindAGrave Suggestions untill next weeks report is run

---

Excellent, thanks for your answer!

Answer 2

Maybe its the "uncertain" in the birth date area. Usually if you have a day, month and year for a date, it is not uncertain. With the FAG memorial maybe you can now mark it as "certain" and elimate the error. (Same for "about").

Comments

That sounds like a good idea, but now I notice that in my other erroneous suggestion, both the birth and death dates are marked as certain. Again, the dates and her name seem to match. Hmm...

 

Suggestion	Link	Info	Name	Rel.	Birth	Death	Gender		Manager	Marriage
572 FindAGrave - Linked grave not matching profile	Kelsey-1308  H	79383697	Maretta Jane Smith (Kelsey)		certain 1849-05-23 Peoria, Union County, Ohio, USA	certain 1915-06-26 Hutchinson, Reno, Kansas, USA	Female		Cebull-1
	79383697		Maretta Jane Kelsey Smith		1849-05-23 Peoria, Union County, Ohio, USA	1915-06-26 Hutchinson, Reno County, Kansas, USA

---

Could it be the order - Maretta Jane Smith (Kelsey) vs Martha Jane Kelsey Smith?

---

Humm Wikitree format is Maretta Jane (Kelsey) Smith or Maretta Jane Smith formerly Kelsey, and FAG is Maretta Jane Kelsey Smith which are actually saying the same thing, Kelsey is LNAB or maiden name. 

I would mark it as false error.