Thank you both for looking into this.
I could not find a death record for John J Reynolds. This has been part of the problem. I was hoping that the death record might list his parents.
Yes, you have the correct family. I have all of what you listed in my family tree. The problem isn't his descendants it is his ancestors!
So now that you have the correct family is there any indication of who the parents are of;
John J. Reynolds
1793 born in either NC or TN
Dies before 1860 in Scottsville, Macoupin, IL