John S Madden wasn't born in Salt Hill. This in incorrect. Please Delete.

+5 votes
587 views
John S Madden , unless you have his birth certificate, with a different place and time.This is wrong.  Please delete.
WikiTree profile: John Madden
in Genealogy Help by
retagged by Lynda Crackett

5 Answers

+11 votes
This can certainly be corrected; can you post your source for his actual birthplace (or a source proving that the given birthplace is wrong)?
by Sharon Casteel G2G6 Pilot (163k points)
Am getting ready here to let some people go,if their not willing to back up what they have posted,and i have given proper instructions ,with out a Union , i am free to fire the person or persons who are not of this family, and placing in false information. Please have your person search the Irish National Archives .ie for the years 1774--1880, clonfert diocease, its free and online.  Your looking for the year 1833, carrarea, fohanagh parish, William and Ella  -Parents, also for Margaret Sarah --July 29th in Carrarea, Fohanagh Parish.   1829, top left hand page. Question Why hasn't Cousin Harry volunteered.  ?  Amazing.
To find this fine Man's mother --since no one wants to search it on in the County of Roscommon Parish  records because that would give a positive and correct source, then you could take the lazy approach and see what someone who has an account on here. Not sure what kind of site it is, don't use it, i just found it.  geni.com/people/William-Madden/60000000571320315 that is Daniel and Mary Margaret Madden's son.  Now if your doing more work on this family, (1)  Not a single set of twins , in the First Generation to immigrate to North America.  (2) I will look up Master Harry Fuller Parker now on Gedmatch, his FTDNA KIT #295391, CAME UP to a ZERO MATCH.   HIS T789207 ..CAME UP WITH ONE SEGMENT, AT 11 CMS..5 .2 GENERATIONS OUT.  THIS MEANS -HE COULD BE (1)  A RELATIVE OF WILLIAM SR. OR ONE OF HIS BROTHERS OR A SISTER.  Kindest  regards
+9 votes
This profile has no manager. Would you be interested in adopting it and helping to improve it? You would be able to correct any data that you consider to be in error and add appropriate sources to support your facts.
by Lynda Crackett G2G6 Pilot (666k points)
+3 votes
Yes , Please delete. He was born elsewhere,  Thank you.
by
+3 votes
Have you deleted this Yet? Did you also go see for your self in the Irish National Archives is is 1833, and not 1835 as you have on here?  Please advise.
by anonymous G2G Rookie (290 points)
Biff we do not delete profiles here, if erroneous information is entered we use sources to correct them

Please join us and correct this profile
Biff, you are responding as though we here at G2G are a single person who is responsible for this profile. I assure you Wikitree is composed of many volunteers, the vast majority of whom have never heard of John S. Madden and have nothing to do with any correct or incorrect information on his profile. You are cordially invited to join Wikitree yourself and provide quality sources to update the profile.
Mr. Marriott, your now making sense, this family did follow the Irish -naming -system -William jr--half son different Mother, so not their first ---First son is Daniel between Marcella and William --he is called after Williams dad,  Daniel--correct- the second son is called after Marcellas Father---Patrick Donilan --Correct -The third son is called after William ---John ----Williams Middle inital is J   for John not Joseph. Daughter Maragaret Sarah  is called after -Mary Margaret -Daniel's Wife. Their is no fourth Daughter.  .To find John S Madden's obit it was published on Feb 25th 1912, in the Sussex, NB ,newspaper with the following  mistake they published 1823, which is wrong   the National Irish archves have 1833.
I was going to take a stab at fixing this, but I am not at all savy on the Ireland stuff - could a leader perhaps put the tags needed so someone who knows their way around Irish Sources could correct this family?
Please delete  our whole family from Daniel ---1753- down -to his Grandson Richard.

I understand you have zero knowledge , of our Family, you did have a person who stated they had DNA match   , but our family ran this in Gedmatch -23 and me  and Ancestry ,no match.
Biff I contacted a guy who is Profile Manager for William the father I think, anyhow he was put off by the way you are demanding deletion.  I had wanted to try and fix the dates and verify and correct the involved profiles, but have not had time.  I was trying to reach out to see if someone more familiar with Irish records but what with the holidays and all have not yet had any luck -

I do not think you are understanding that we are all volunteers here and we are not paid or anything, we work on what we can when we can and let me assure you you are at the top of my to do list.  If your patience is wearing thin, and you have those sources all already I might suggest again that you join WikiTree and fix up these profiles yourself, as I am sure it would be much easier for you -

Again we do not delete here, we correct

If you do not want to join and help you must be patient

thanks

Navarro
Mr Narvarro , Since this is  posted by my family members, and since your not willing to accept what our Family has discovered, i have no idea who else is posting here, bedsides my own family members, then to whom ever your talking about, isn't my family. So what your saying for this to be deleted one of our family members has to sign up again , to delete this.   Correct.
To Correct is to DELETE. AGREED .

KINDLY DELETE, WITH INFORM OUR FAMILY !  

Merry Christmas!   Finally you listened.

Biff, three days ago you said, “ Please delete  our whole family from Daniel ---1753- down -to his Grandson Richard.”

This is just not going to happen. I’m going state again what has been said above by others, we do not delete profiles. We correct them. 

You once began the process of joining WikiTree, but did not follow up. If you join, you can make the necessary efforts to correct information based on he sources you have discovered. I know you feel frustrated by incorrect information. Many of us deal with the same problems with our ancestors.

One thing you need to understand is that profiles, even families may be managed by people who are not related to them. I have several families that I am not related to (directly) that I research and manage.

We share our one tree where all of us are responsible for the quality of the work. It’s not perfect, but we strive to make our Shared Tree the best it can be. Whether one is related to your family or not has no bearing on whether or not they appear on WikiTree.

The tone of your responses do not help you to accomplish the corrections you wish to see. Will you not join us as a full member to raise the quality of our Shared Tree where your expertise can assist us?

Sheppard, my Tone!   This isn't your family, and just so you know their are people on here who are profiting from your poor quality of Work.   Why are you letting people Profit from these errors, your not the who has to correct this mess, i do.

I'm trying to stop these but you will not help.  So I will let you put it on your concience.

Not my Fault.
+4 votes
Spent about three hours on this and could not get very far, but Bifford, I do believe that you are worried about a different family with the same name - this batch is not lining up with the information you provided at all - Now as I said before I am not versed in looking for Irish records and I really tried and failed to confirm your information so far
by Navarro Mariott G2G6 Pilot (165k points)

Related questions

+4 votes
1 answer
+14 votes
3 answers
+3 votes
0 answers
+9 votes
1 answer
+4 votes
2 answers
+5 votes
0 answers
149 views asked Jan 28, 2015 in Genealogy Help by anonymous G2G Crew (610 points)
+3 votes
0 answers
133 views asked Apr 10, 2014 in Genealogy Help by anonymous
+2 votes
1 answer
199 views asked Nov 17, 2013 in Genealogy Help by Michelle Walsh G2G Rookie (190 points)
+1 vote
1 answer
302 views asked Jun 18, 2012 in Genealogy Help by anonymous

WikiTree  ~  About  ~  Help Help  ~  Search Person Search  ~  Surname:

disclaimer - terms - copyright

...