PGM Change LNAB to Carver [closed]

Question

See:  Anderson, Robert C. The Wives of Michael Barstow and Richard Carver of Watertown, Massachusetts, and The Identity of the Wives of William Randall of Scituate and William Perry of Marshfield. The New England Historical and Genealogical Register, Volume 146 pp. 230-4 (Online database: AmericanAncestors.org, New England Historic Genealogical Society, 2001-2013.)  Requires subscription: https://www.americanancestors.org/DB202/i/11691/230/235119294

Robert Anderson has postulated that Susan (sic Barstow) that married William Perry, is the daughter of Richard Carver and his wife Margaret Skurrie as follows:  

Richard and Margaret (Skurrie) Carver had twin daughters, Elizabeth and Susan, baptized at Filby, Norfolk on October 15, 1618.  Margaret was buried shortly after the birth of these twins on November 16, 1618.   Richards' second wife Elizabeth died in 1622.  

Richard married 3rd, Grace Walker in 1623.  

Richard Carver, wife Grace and their twin daughters Elizabeth and Susan Carver sailed from Yarmouth, Norfolk to New England in 1637.

Richard's will written in 1638, was proved on September 9, 1641 leaving his estate to Grace, Elizabeth and Susan.

His widow Grace, married Michael Barstow, as his third wife.

Michael Barstow had no children by his three wives, so the Susan Perry, wife of William in his will would be his stepdaughter Susan Carver.

Change he LNAB to Carver based on the above - or change to Unknown as this has not been proven?

See also G2G:  https://www.wikitree.com/g2g/537400/disconnect-william-barstow-alleged-children-matthew-barstow

Comments

That's convoluted, I'm going to have to read the article again, maybe twice.

---

I think that's good enough to change the LNAB to Carver, but there should be an indication of uncertainty.

---

The article kept putting me to sleep, but I agree with Ellen. I was always suspicious that she wasn't a sister of the Barstow boys. I also added some of the facts from the article to Richard Carver.

I'm not totally convinced that the brother, John, is Michael's brother, but Anderson agrees he is, so I can't help but think there is some evidence that I haven't located

Thanks Chris

---

I've finished disconnecting the Barstow brothers from their alleged father Matthew. I see there is already a profile for Susan (Carver) Perry. So you will be able to disconnect Barstow-212 and merge her into Carver-1636. There seems to be another Susan Carver duplicate also to merge.

Thank you Chris.

---

Thanks Anne - merges have been proposed.