so sorry you had to go through that. I always search for matches first, then create a new profile. There should have been an option to click that would've created the new Sarah Jane Clark profile that you entered the infromation for ... off to the right or toward the bottom? (It's been ages since I've created a profile, so I don't quite remember. But when the list comes up, look it over & if something looks promising that you hadn't seen before, open that profile in a new tab to look at closer after you create the one with all your information.)
Hang in there, and fingers crossed you don't have to experience this again!