Can you please outline your personal approach and what it involves? Can you provide some justification?
Can you also please outline what questions you are seeking answers for? and how this does not address them?
I don't see how giving a person a first name that refers to their Nation as respectful, nor does it help connect them to their family which is what the LNAB field is intended for. Or is this misguided Australia Chris?
Does how you write your proposals "use their conventions instead of ours." or just your 'expert personal approach'. I cannot see a single 'Palawa' profile that does this for example.
The profile for Kudnarto described her 'yerta' when she was born in quite specific detail. This represents her clan or her 'mob', quite specifically. It represents the name passed down by her family with which she identifies with.
Indigenous ways of knowing involve identifying themselves based on their connection to clan and country their 'mob'.
This is why including this as a LNAB is important
Kudarto or the correct name she was given after she survived infancy is not this kind of name. The way she would identify with her family is by her clan or mob. Kudnarto's yerta is 'Padnaindi' by the convention of "use their conventions instead of ours." this should be used and why I have chosen to link this discussion to specific profiles rather than being philosophical abou it. This is the way Indigenous Australians identify themselves still today. It is established and strong part of culture.
Last Name at Birth
This field could also be called Proper Last Name, Surname, or Maiden Name.
It is generally a family name but it could be a patronymic or whatever other standard is conventional for the person's time and place.
It is usually the formal name as it appears in official documents at the time of birth. However, it may not be exactly what appears in a birth record if:
- There was a spelling mistake or error in the document, or if the family name was more commonly spelled in a different way at the time of the birth (see the spelling conventions section above).
- The person was adopted as an infant and they never used their birth name.
"Dit" names should not go in this field. They can go in the Current Last Name, Other Last Name, or Nickname field, as appropriate.
If the last name is unknown, use Unknown in the field. Do not use Not Sure, NN, Wife of X, Adopted, etc.
Kudnarto was clearly a first name at birth and if you read her profile this is very very clear. It fits the definition of a proper first name by the convention of "use their conventions instead of ours."
Proper First Name
This field could also be called Formal First Name or First Name at Birth.
This is the formal given name that would appear in official documents.
If a person's name officially changed during their lifetime, this field should contain their first name at birth — unless their first name was officially changed soon after birth, e.g. with an infant adoption, or if the birth certificate was amended or corrected. You may want to put their first name at death in the Preferred First Name field but that field is not as formal. (See below). Either way, explain the name change in the biographical text.
This is a required field and cannot be left blank.
- If you're unsure of the Proper First Name, enter Unknown. If you can make an educated guess, enter that and mark the status as "uncertain". You might also wish to explain it in the biographical text. Do not use NN, or something like Twin, Daughter of X, Husband of Y, etc.
- If an infant died before he or she could be named use what is on their death record according to their conventions, otherwise use Unnamed Infant. Do not use Infant Boy, Baby Girl, etc. There is a gender field for this.
- If you want extra privacy enter Anonymous or the first initial. Do not enter Living or a fake name or alias.