Thanks for looking at the Carrico's for me, you found another that enters into the mix. Looking at this again it looks to me that Peter Carrico-23, 24, 152, and 223 are the same person. He would be the son of Peter Carrico-513. It's interesting that Peter, Sr shares the same wife as the son, obviously that is incorrect. The son's wife, Margaret and Ann Gates, is also duplicated as Gates-1908, 2641, and 1090. I'm thinking that her name is actually Margaret Ann Gates.
So much more to dig into. I'm able to trace my direct ancestors back to Vincent Carrico-544 and think I may be part of Peter's line somehow. Just have to prove it.