He was born about 1871, in England and was in Fulton, Ohio to marry Ophie B Gamble on 28 Sep 1893, and in Gorham, Ohio in 1910 according to census data. Aside from that, most of the records I've found are about his 5 daughter's births and four surviving daughters getting married.
My grandmother thought she remembered something about he might have been adopted, but wasn't sure, and has no idea if Tillotson would be the adopting family or the birth family if he was adopted. I have no information on who raised him.
I'd like to try working the Tillotson's from England and Ohio to see who may have lost Herbert, or traveled with him, in case it is his birth surname, or if he appears anywhere as a child adopted or not, but there seem to be so many Tillotson's. I'm not really sure where or how to start chiseling down my brick wall from the other side.
I would appreciate any tips or help finding his immigration records