But the 239987 is the correct one - it just doesn't have all of its information sourced yet.
There is a plethora of documentation available that states he was born 13 Aug 1757, died 8 Jun 1802, and served as a Sergeant. He was married to Philomela Loomis on 17 Dec 1781 in Lebanon-Goshen, New London, Connecticut, United States, and they had a daughter, Clarissa.
I was also able to locate your noted SAR membership application where George Albert Smith, Jr. stated most of the above