Hi Jenn, I don't see the third profile. To begin with, that unmerged match was probably set due to conflicting information on the profiles. If you really think that they are the same then you need to remove the Unmerged Match and initiate a new merge.
So that extra redirects aren't caused, you would want to look at all three. Merge one of the extras into the lowest White-#. Once that is completed, merge the other one into the lowest White-#.