login
Questions
Unanswered
Tags
Users
Ask a Question
My Feed
G2G Help
Categories
All categories
The Tree House
(45.2k)
Appreciation
(19.3k)
Genealogy Help
(99.0k)
Photos
(5.4k)
Policy and Style
(16.1k)
Requests for Project Volunteers
(3.3k)
WikiTree Help
(16.1k)
WikiTree Tech
(17.2k)
Why a nonsense birthdate?
+3
votes
209
views
Simeon Harris was born 1761, and died 1847 in what's now West Virginia. She was 1at wife. 2nd wife was Hannah Smith.
I notice he married her (Christina Westfall) on Dec. 20, 1784. That can't also be her birthdate.
WikiTree profile:
Christina Harris
westfall
sources
asked
Aug 1, 2018
in
Genealogy Help
by
Carl Moore
This often happens because "before" and "after" used to be lost.
Easy enough to fix. I don’t think people should be so hesitant to fix obvious errors. When giving an estimated date it is always good to provide the reasoning in case someone can improve on the date later.
Please
log in
or
register
to add a comment.
Please
log in
or
register
to answer this question.
1
Answer
+10
votes
Best answer
It looks like a typo. A search of Ancestry produced
https://www.ancestry.com/family-tree/person/tree/1592804/person/-1914719847/facts?ssrc=
which says birth year 1764. The tree is essentially unsourced but mentions a county history for the marriage date. Ancestry does have some better records.
answered
Aug 1, 2018
by
Doug McCallum
G2G6 Pilot
(
534k
points)
selected
Aug 1, 2018
by
Maggie N.
Please
log in
or
register
to add a comment.
Related questions
+8
votes
1
answer
136
views
Stephen Westfall is a Wonderful WikiTreer
asked
Jul 20, 2022
in
Appreciation
by
Rick Lear
G2G2
(
2.2k
points)
wonderful_wikitreers
westfall
+9
votes
1
answer
249
views
New member introducing myself
asked
Apr 21, 2022
in
The Tree House
by
Stephen Westfall
G2G Crew
(
830
points)
westfall
davis
doering
henkes
graham
keeland
+12
votes
8
answers
594
views
Westfalls on WikiTree - Annual Report
asked
Dec 11, 2021
in
The Tree House
by
Greg Slade
G2G6 Pilot
(
679k
points)
westfall
one_name_studies
connectors
sourcerers
notables
+5
votes
3
answers
317
views
Can someone at NNS take this? if I find one more set of duplicates today I will scream
asked
Jun 16, 2018
in
Genealogy Help
by
Navarro Mariott
G2G6 Pilot
(
167k
points)
merges
new_netherland
westfall
westfael
arborists
+4
votes
1
answer
91
views
what cemetary was david dwight westfall buried in in 1991
asked
Apr 9, 2018
in
Genealogy Help
by
anonymous
westfall
+8
votes
2
answers
252
views
Born 1854 in VA and part of the New Netherland Settlers Project
asked
Feb 6, 2016
in
Genealogy Help
by
James Applegate
G2G6 Mach 5
(
57.4k
points)
westfall
new_netherland
projects
+2
votes
0
answers
114
views
Looking for more information on my great-grandmother, where did she go after her marriage to Jones Tindle?
asked
Jul 30, 2014
in
Genealogy Help
by
Charlotte Amodeo
G2G Crew
(
340
points)
westfall
holland
+5
votes
0
answers
134
views
birth certificate for alice ann westfall
asked
Jun 26, 2014
in
Genealogy Help
by
Living Paul
G2G Rookie
(
280
points)
westfall
+8
votes
5
answers
343
views
Nonsense Ancestry sources and No access
asked
Mar 6, 2021
in
Genealogy Help
by
Cliff Parnell
G2G3
(
3.4k
points)
ancestry
sources
gedcom
+9
votes
3
answers
151
views
bug in the system, telling me invalid charater in marriage location, which is nonsense
asked
Mar 1, 2021
in
WikiTree Tech
by
Danielle Liard
G2G6 Pilot
(
659k
points)
tracked_bug
WikiTree
~
About
~
Help
~
Search
~
Surname
:
...