Hello Brooke and Welcome to WikiTree!
There is a John Cooley (1858) listed on WikiTree along with other John Cooley's.
Once you add a profile for your John Cooley you will have an opportunity to compare him to other John Cooley's. You might get lucky and get your answer. Also, add this question to his profile in the comments section. That way others who might be interested in the Cooley name will see it.