Did Ah Nee Wa Kee Ah-qua-ta-Kee exist?

+3 votes
579 views
Can anyone find documentation (actual historical records, not other web pages or genealogy sites) to show that either An Nee Wa Kee Ah-qua-ta-Kee "Wild Potato Clan" Moytoy or her purported husband, Felix (Ah-qua-ta-kee) Ah-qua-ta-kee Aquatake [Ah-qua-ta-kee-1] actually existed?  There are numerous children attached to this woman, most of whom are also undocumented, unrelated, and/or of uncertain existence.

Cornelius Dougherty, listed as the second husband, was a real person, a trader to the Cherokee from about 1720-1770.  He had children by one or more unknown Cherokee women; a daughter named Jane/Jennie and a son named James are the only ones positively documented as his.  James Hicks "Descendants of Cornelius Dougherty" lists a woman of the Wild Potato Clan named A-nu-we-gi as one of Dougherty's wives.  Her name is unsupported by any documentation. Hicks attempted to reverse engineer clan affiliations from later individuals whose clan was known.  It's my belief that many of his early women's names were created by him simply to identify different wives in his trees since no Cherokee women are mentioned by name in early records..
 
The first source listed for this profile is an unsourced book by Donald Yates.  Yates believes that the Cherokee are actually Middle Eastern/Jewish and has written numerous books and articles in support of his claim.

The second source is a dead link..

The third source is Emmett Starr's History of the Cherokee which does not mention either Ah nee wa kee or Felix at any point.

The fourth source is a dead link to an Ancestry tree; searching on Ancestry finds her as part of the mythical Thomas Pasmere Carpenter tree..

The fifth source is a link to an undocumented profile on Geni.

The only source for Felix is also an undocumented Geni profile.
WikiTree profile: Ah Nee Wa Kee Moytoy
in Genealogy Help by Kathie Forbes G2G6 Pilot (867k points)
edited by Kathie Forbes
Thanks for retrieving it, although it makes no mention of the profile person and turns out to be someone’s undocumented web page.
Should we remove her name but leave her as the unnamed Native American (Cherokee?) wife of Cornelius Doherty?
That might be a good solution.  That would leave Felix out in the ether, but I cannot find anything to suggest he ever existed.  Cornelius Daugherty's mythical children need removing, too.
Flagging this... Kathie, your original post mentions Donald Yates. I wonder if this is the same man who created DNA Consultants...?
Yes, it is.  This “family” seems to be a modern invention of Don Green and Donald Yates.  The Eastern Cherokee applications only reference an ancestor named “Betsy Walker” no parents, no “Cherokee” names.

3 Answers

+1 vote
I'm not sure if this is of any value with the whole "Moytoy" family issues, but thought i would post it, just incase there is any use or helps to either disconnect or connect.  This is a Genealogical looks like family "report", that appears may have taken years, and a number of researchers, but again, not sure.. Anyway it appears to be filled with actual dates, places, record #s, Rolls #s  & specifics of each person on each roll, then their connected marrgs, children etc.  I don't know how factual it is, since it does bring up EBC and Okl  as well as mentions Moytoy, and others.  will let you all decide if theres' any value to it or if it maybe a source of where some are getting their "info's" from to connect within different lines.

http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:hg8mFNLEQWwJ:thehennesseefamily.com/ahnentafel.php%3FpersonID%3DI33147%26tree%3Dhennessee%26parentset%3D%26generations%3D%26tngmore%3D1+&cd=14&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=us&client=opera
by Arora Anonymous G2G6 Pilot (164k points)
I think this is just one of many family trees that have tacked on Internet junk to go back more generations than the facts will support.  I’m pretty sure Ahneewakee is one of Don Greene’s inventions,
+1 vote
If people believe this woman existed can we at least detach her from Cornelius Dougherty and his two actual children?  There is no contemporaneous record that gives a name to the Cherokee wife (or wives) of Cornelius Dougherty.
by Kathie Forbes G2G6 Pilot (867k points)
+1 vote
I think we should just detach her, but not delete her. There all kinds of legends about the wives of some of the men, and I have found some of those legends to be true.
by Cheryl Hess G2G Astronaut (1.8m points)

Related questions

+3 votes
2 answers
+3 votes
3 answers
+4 votes
1 answer
+10 votes
0 answers
+7 votes
4 answers

WikiTree  ~  About  ~  Help Help  ~  Search Person Search  ~  Surname:

disclaimer - terms - copyright

...